Unilateral climate-linked trade measures such as CBAM undermine the principle of CBDR-RC. Discuss India's position and options.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Article 3.1 of the UNFCCC asks Parties to act on the basis of equity and Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC). Article 3.5 says climate measures, including unilateral ones, must not become a disguised restriction on trade [1]. The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) has been in its definitive regime since January 2026 [2]. It tests both principles because it shifts the cost of mitigation onto the Global South.
How CBAM strains CBDR-RC
- Uniform carbon price: imports are charged on their embedded emissions in line with the EU's ETS. It takes no account of historical responsibility or capability [2].
- High trade cost, low climate gain: ICRIER projects that Indian steel exports to the EU will fall by ~24%, while global steel emissions fall by only ~1% [3].
- Compliance burden: CBAM requires verified emissions data for each plant [2], which MSMEs struggle to produce.
- The EU's view: CBAM moves in step with the phase-out of free ETS allowances. The EU presents it as climate policy, not protectionism [2].
India's position
- Legal objection: India treats such measures as breaching Article 3.5 and CBDR-RC. With BASIC, it sought a COP28 agenda item on unilateral trade measures [4].
- Multilateral setback: at COP31, the revised draft cover text dropped earlier language on phasing out measures like CBAM by 2027 [5].
- Finance before penalties: India argues that developed countries should fund the transition, not tax it. Developing countries' adaptation needs exceed $310 billion a year by 2035, about 12 times current flows [6].
India's options
- Diplomatic: keep raising Article 3.5 at the UNFCCC with BASIC and the LMDC. Keep the WTO route open in reserve.
- Domestic carbon pricing: expand the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS), which sets emission-intensity targets for energy-intensive sectors [7]. India can then press the EU in trade talks to credit the carbon price already paid at home.
- Industrial upgrading: move towards higher value-added, lower-carbon steel, as ICRIER recommends [3]. Support green hydrogen.
- MSME support: public help for exporters to measure, report and verify their emissions.
- Market diversification: sell more to buyers that do not apply CBAM.
CBAM pits the EU's climate ambition against equity for the Global South. India's best response combines multilateral pressure with domestic decarbonisation that holds up to verification. That would turn CBAM from a trade barrier into a reason to modernise industry. Climate action consistent with SDG 13 and the Paris Agreement's spirit of equity has to rest on cooperation, not unilateral levies.
Sources
- 1United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, 1992 – Article 3 (UNFCCC)CBDR-RC (Art. 3.1); unilateral measures must not be a disguised restriction on trade (Art. 3.5)
- 2CBAM definitive regime – Taxation and Customs Union, European Commissiondefinitive regime from 1 Jan 2026; verified plant-level emissions; phase-in alongside the phase-out of free ETS allowances
- 3ICRIER: CBAM – Impact on India's Steel Exports to the EU and Carbon Tax Incidence~24% fall in steel exports to the EU; ~1% fall in global steel emissions; shift to higher value-added steel
- 4BASIC Agenda Proposal to the COP28 Presidency (UNFCCC)BASIC sought an agenda item on unilateral trade-restrictive measures
- 5Draft of COP31 cover text drops references to fossil fuel phase-out, net zero dates – The Hindu, 20 Nov 2026revised draft dropped language on phasing out unilateral trade measures like CBAM by 2027
- 6UNEP Adaptation Gap Report 2025: Running on Emptyadaptation needs over $310 bn a year by 2035, about 12 times current flows
- 7PIB: Carbon Credit Trading Scheme, 2026CCTS notified; emission-intensity targets for energy-intensive sectors