·The Hindu

SC dismisses plea against animal killing during religious ceremonies

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Mains Relevance
  9. Related Topics to Study Next
  10. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  11. Common Errors / Trap Areas

1. At a Glance

  • On 18 November 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed a plea to ban the killing of animals during religious ceremonies, including animal sacrifice in temples [1].
  • The petition wanted the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (PCA) Act, 1960 amended, because the Act exempts killing animals as part of religious rituals and practices [1]. This exemption is Section 28 [2].
  • The case is a textbook clash between three things: freedom of religion (Art. 25), animal welfare (Art. 51A(g) and the PCA Act), and how far courts should go in telling Parliament to amend a law [2].
  • It is relevant to GS-II (polity, judiciary, rights) and GS-IV (ethics of how humans treat animals).

2. Why in the News

  • 18 November 2026 (Wednesday): A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh dismissed the plea after hearing the petitioner [1].
  • Petitioner: advocate Shruti Bisht [1].
  • The Bench refused to allow any intervention in the plea. It said interveners could file separate petitions [1].
  • Earlier in the case, the Court had sought a response from the Union Ministry of Animal Husbandry [1].
  • The excerpt does not give the Court's reasons for dismissing the plea. Do not assume the Court ruled on the constitutionality of Section 28.

3. Background & Evolution

  • 1960: Parliament enacted the PCA Act, 1960. It contains a saving clause for killing animals "in a manner required by the religion of any community" (Section 28) [1][2].
  • 1954, Shirur Mutt: The SC set out the Essential Religious Practices (ERP) test. Under it, Art. 25 protects only practices that are essential to a religion [2].
  • 1958, Mohd. Hanif Qureshi v. State of Bihar: The SC held that cow sacrifice on Bakrid is not an essential religious practice [2].
  • 1976, 42nd Amendment: It added Art. 51A(g), the duty to show compassion for living creatures. It also added Entry 17B, Concurrent List (protection of wild animals and birds) [2].
  • 2014, AWBI v. A. Nagaraja (Jallikattu): The SC recognised the "five freedoms" of animals and read animal welfare into Art. 21 [2].
  • 2023: A Constitution Bench upheld state amendments to the PCA Act that permit Jallikattu, Kambala and bullock-cart races [2].
  • State laws: Some states ban animal sacrifice, such as the Karnataka Prevention of Animal Sacrifices Act, 1959 and the Kerala Animals and Birds Sacrifices Prohibition Act, 1968 [2].
  • 2026: The petitioner argued that animal sacrifice, although it had declined at first, continues in several regions: the Himalayan region, north-eastern India, parts of Odisha and West Bengal, and Maharashtra [1].

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Statute challenged Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 [1]
Provision Section 28: killing an animal in a manner required by the religion of any community is not an offence [2]
Main cruelty offence Section 11 (treating animals cruelly) [2]
Statutory body Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI), set up under Section 4; formed in 1962 [2]
Ministry made respondent Union Ministry of Animal Husbandry [1]. This is the Department of Animal Husbandry & Dairying under the Ministry of Fisheries, Animal Husbandry & Dairying [2]
Legislative entry Entry 17, List III (Concurrent): "Prevention of cruelty to animals" [2]
Constitutional provisions involved Art. 25 (religion, subject to public order, morality and health), Art. 26, Art. 48 (animal husbandry, cow slaughter), Art. 51A(g) (compassion for living creatures) [2]
Bench (18 Nov 2026) Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan, Aparesh Kumar Singh JJ. [1]
Regions named in the plea Himalayan region, NE India, Odisha, West Bengal, Maharashtra [1]

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Legal / Constitutional

  • Section 28 is a legislative choice to protect religious practice. Changing it needs an amendment by Parliament, and courts generally do not issue a mandamus telling the legislature to legislate [1][2].
  • The ERP doctrine is the usual test. If sacrifice is not essential to a faith, it can be regulated under the Art. 25(1) limits of "public order, morality and health" [2].
  • Art. 51A(g) is a fundamental duty. It cannot be enforced directly, but courts use it to interpret statutes [2].
  • Refusing interventions and pointing interveners to separate petitions keeps the PIL procedurally narrow [1].

Social / Cultural

  • Animal sacrifice is part of folk, tribal and Shakta traditions in the regions the plea names [1][2]. A blanket ban would raise questions about minority and tribal cultural rights (Art. 29) [2].
  • The petitioner said the practice is still going on even though it has declined [1]. Social reform versus state coercion is the core tension.

Ethical (GS-IV)

  • Animal rights (sentience, the five freedoms) versus religious autonomy. One is a utilitarian or rights-based ethic, the other cultural relativism.
  • Consistency problem: the law allows commercial slaughter but questions ritual killing. Is the objection to killing itself, or to how the animal is killed?

Governance / Federal

  • Animal cruelty is a Concurrent List subject, so states can and do pass their own bans, as Karnataka and Kerala have [2].
  • The Centre is involved through the Ministry of Animal Husbandry [1] and the AWBI [2].

Public Health / Environmental

  • Mass sacrifice at public sites raises concerns about sanitation, carcass disposal and zoonoses. These fall under the Art. 25 "health" limit [2].

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 2025–26: Advocate Shruti Bisht filed a PIL to amend the PCA Act and to direct authorities to stop animals being killed during religious ceremonies [1].
  • Pre-hearing stage: The SC sought the Union Ministry of Animal Husbandry's response [1].
  • 18 November 2026: The SC dismissed the plea and refused interventions, leaving interveners free to file separate petitions [1].

7. Prelims Hooks

  • The SC dismissed the plea against animal killing in religious ceremonies on 18 November 2026 [1].
  • Bench: Justices Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan, Aparesh Kumar Singh [1].
  • Petitioner: advocate Shruti Bisht [1].
  • Statute: Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 [1].
  • The PCA Act exempts killing of animals as part of religious rituals [1]. The provision is Section 28 [2].
  • Respondent ministry: Union Ministry of Animal Husbandry, not MoEFCC [1].
  • Interveners were told to file separate petitions [1].
  • "Prevention of cruelty to animals" is Entry 17, Concurrent List [2].
  • Art. 51A(g) (compassion for living creatures) was added by the 42nd Amendment, 1976 [2].
  • AWBI is a statutory body under Section 4 of the PCA Act, set up in 1962 [2].
  • Essential Religious Practices test: Shirur Mutt (1954) [2].
  • Mohd. Hanif Qureshi (1958): cow sacrifice on Bakrid is not an essential religious practice [2].
  • Five freedoms of animals: AWBI v. A. Nagaraja (2014) [2].

8. Mains Relevance

  • GS-II: Fundamental Rights (Art. 25–26), Fundamental Duties, the judiciary (PIL, judicial restraint), statutory bodies (AWBI).
  • GS-I: Indian society, religious and tribal practices, secularism.
  • GS-IV: Ethics in human–animal relations; conflicting values.
  • Possible questions: 1. "Section 28 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 reflects a constitutional compromise between Article 25 and Article 51A(g). Critically examine in light of the Supreme Court's recent refusal to strike it down." (15 marks) 2. "The Essential Religious Practices doctrine has made courts arbiters of theology. Discuss with reference to cases on animal sacrifice." (10 marks) 3. "Should social reform of religious practices come through legislation, judicial intervention or community persuasion? Analyse using animal sacrifice as a case study." (GS-IV, 10 marks)

9. Related Topics to Study Next

  • Essential Religious Practices doctrine (Shirur Mutt, Sabarimala 2018): the main test for whether Art. 25 protects a ritual.
  • Jallikattu cases (2014, 2023): the same PCA Act tension between culture and cruelty.
  • Cow slaughter laws and Art. 48: state bans and Hanif Qureshi / Mirzapur Moti Kureshi (2005).
  • Animal Welfare Board of India: its structure, ministry and powers.
  • Fundamental Duties (Part IVA): whether they can be enforced, and how courts use them to interpret laws.
  • PIL and judicial restraint: limits on courts directing Parliament to legislate.
  • State anti-sacrifice laws (Karnataka 1959, Kerala 1968): Concurrent List federalism in practice.
  • Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972: often confused with the PCA Act; it covers wild animals.

10. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Essential religious practices doctrine (Polity): The main court test for whether a ritual like animal sacrifice is protected under Article 25.
  • Freedom of religion (Polity): Article 25 religious freedom is one side of the clash with animal welfare.
  • Fundamental duties (Polity): Article 51A(g), compassion for living creatures, is the duty used to argue for animal welfare.
  • 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act 1976 (Polity): This amendment added Article 51A(g) and the Fundamental Duties that the animal-welfare argument rests on.
  • Concurrent List (Polity): Prevention of cruelty to animals is a Concurrent List subject, so states like Karnataka and Kerala can ban sacrifice.
  • Public interest litigation (Polity): The case came as a PIL filed by an advocate, and the Court limited who could intervene.
  • Judicial restraint (Polity): Courts hesitate to tell Parliament to amend a law, which explains why the plea was dismissed.
  • Mandamus (Polity): Courts generally cannot issue a writ ordering the legislature to amend or make a law.
  • Jallikattu (Polity): The 2023 Jallikattu ruling is the closest precedent on culture versus cruelty under the same Act.
  • Statutory body (Polity): The Animal Welfare Board of India is a statutory body created under the PCA Act.
  • Cultural rights (Polity): A blanket ban on sacrifice would raise questions about tribal and minority cultural rights under Article 29.
  • Wildlife (Protection) Act 1972 (Geography): It is often confused with the PCA Act, since it covers only wild species.
  • Public order (Polity): Article 25 allows religious practices to be restricted on grounds of public order, morality and health.

11. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Wrong ministry: the PCA Act and AWBI fall under Animal Husbandry (Fisheries, Animal Husbandry & Dairying), not MoEFCC [1][2].
  • Wrong list: "Prevention of cruelty to animals" is in the Concurrent List (Entry 17), not the State List. The State List has animal husbandry and preservation of stock (Entry 15) [2].
  • Reading too much into the dismissal: dismissing the PIL is not a ruling that upholds Section 28's constitutionality. The excerpt gives no reasons [1].
  • PCA Act vs Wildlife (Protection) Act: the PCA Act (1960) covers cruelty to all animals; the WPA (1972) covers wild species and their habitats [2].
  • Year confusion: PCA Act 1960; AWBI 1962; Art. 51A(g) 1976 [2].

Sources

  1. 1SC dismisses plea against animal killing during religious ceremonies, The Hindu (PTI), 18 Nov 2026:thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2: standard statutory and constitutional facts from memory, not retrieved in this session. Confirm them at indiacode.nic.in (PCA Act, 1960) and constitutionofindia.net.

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 19 November

All 19 November articles →