"Civilisational dialogue can complement the security-centric agenda of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation." Discuss with reference to India's recent initiatives.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The SCO was founded in 2001 and now has 10 members [2]. Its work has centred on security, especially counter-terrorism, alongside economy and connectivity. On 20 November 2026, India inaugurated the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in Delhi, adding a cultural track [1]. This track can deepen the security core, but it cannot replace it.
Why a security-only agenda falls short
- Rivalries among members, India–Pakistan and India–China, limit consensus. India has had to press the SCO to call out states that shelter terrorists [4].
- Trust deficits stall joint positions. A track that does not need agreement on contested issues keeps engagement alive.
How civilisational dialogue complements it: India's initiatives
- Agenda-setting: India proposed the Forum at the 25th SCO Summit in Tianjin (2025) [3]. During its earlier chairmanship it had already added Shared Buddhist Heritage as a pillar of cooperation [2].
- Shared memory as a trust-builder: The PM's address recalled two-way flows of ideas [1]:
- the Panchatantra became Kalila wa Dimna in Persian and Arabic;
- Brahmagupta's mathematics was taken further by al-Khwarizmi in Baghdad;
- Kumarajiva translated Buddhist texts into Chinese;
-
the garden traditions of Samarkand and Herat shaped the Charbagh style.
-
Concrete proposals [1]:
- joint digitisation and AI-aided translation of manuscripts;
- heritage circuits along the Silk Routes and Buddhist sites;
-
scholar and artist exchanges.
-
People-centric: Scholars, artists and youth keep ties going even when relations between governments sour [1].
- Values: Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam frames cooperation as a positive-sum effort, not zero-sum bargaining over security [1].
Limitations
- Culture cannot settle cross-border terrorism. India keeps a firm line in the security track [4].
- Geography is contested. Key nodes such as Gandhara, Kucha and Dunhuang [1] lie in Pakistan, Afghanistan and China. China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan have already jointly listed 33 Silk Road sites with UNESCO, and India is not part of that listing [6].
- India's own base is thin. Over 1.19 crore manuscripts have been identified [5], but only about 8 lakh are digitised under Gyan Bharatam [7].
- No institutional backing yet: the Forum has no secretariat, budget or meeting calendar, so it risks staying ceremonial.
Civilisational dialogue is therefore a complement to the SCO's security agenda, not a cure for it. It builds trust where the security track builds deterrence. The way forward:
- a standing SCO working group with yearly targets for translations and exchanges;
- priority digitisation of Buddhist, Persian and Sanskrit-mathematics collections;
- heritage circuits that start with willing Central Asian partners.
This dual track, firm on terror and open on culture, reflects the Vedic call "Sangachhadhvam samvadadhvam" (move together, speak together) [1]. It also supports India's vision of the world as one family.
Sources
- 1PIB: Text of PM's address at the inauguration of the First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, Old Fort, Delhi (20 Nov 2026)Forum's date and venue, the transmission examples, the proposals, people-centric focus, Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and the Vedic verse *(the exact release page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*
- 2MEA: SCO brief (21 Aug 2025)and [MEA: India–SCO Cooperation](https://www.mea.gov.in/Portal/ForeignRelation/India-SCO_Cooperation.pdf) — SCO founded 2001, 10 members, Shared Buddhist Heritage pillar
- 3New India Samachar (PIB), 1–15 October 2025, p. 48PM proposed the Civilisational Dialogue Forum at the 25th SCO Summit, Tianjin
- 4PIB: "Every act of terrorism is criminal & unjustifiable…": Raksha Mantri at SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting, Qingdao (June 2025)India pressing the SCO on terrorism and its sponsors *(the exact release page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*
- 5PIB: Ministry of Culture press release on the Gyan Bharatam manuscript surveyover 1.19 crore manuscripts identified
- 6UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Silk Roads: the Routes Network of Chang'an–Tianshan Corridor33 sites listed jointly by China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan in 2014
- 7PIB Factsheet: Gyan Bharatam Missionabout 8 lakh manuscripts digitised *(the factsheet page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*