·PIB·15 marks·250–350 wordsHistoryCultureIR

"Civilisational dialogue can complement the security-centric agenda of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation." Discuss with reference to India's recent initiatives.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why a security-only agenda falls short
  2. How civilisational dialogue complements it: India's initiatives
  3. Limitations

The SCO was founded in 2001 and now has 10 members [2]. Its work has centred on security, especially counter-terrorism, alongside economy and connectivity. On 20 November 2026, India inaugurated the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in Delhi, adding a cultural track [1]. This track can deepen the security core, but it cannot replace it.

Why a security-only agenda falls short

  • Rivalries among members, India–Pakistan and India–China, limit consensus. India has had to press the SCO to call out states that shelter terrorists [4].
  • Trust deficits stall joint positions. A track that does not need agreement on contested issues keeps engagement alive.

How civilisational dialogue complements it: India's initiatives

  • Agenda-setting: India proposed the Forum at the 25th SCO Summit in Tianjin (2025) [3]. During its earlier chairmanship it had already added Shared Buddhist Heritage as a pillar of cooperation [2].
  • Shared memory as a trust-builder: The PM's address recalled two-way flows of ideas [1]:
  • the Panchatantra became Kalila wa Dimna in Persian and Arabic;
  • Brahmagupta's mathematics was taken further by al-Khwarizmi in Baghdad;
  • Kumarajiva translated Buddhist texts into Chinese;
  • the garden traditions of Samarkand and Herat shaped the Charbagh style.

  • Concrete proposals [1]:

  • joint digitisation and AI-aided translation of manuscripts;
  • heritage circuits along the Silk Routes and Buddhist sites;
  • scholar and artist exchanges.

  • People-centric: Scholars, artists and youth keep ties going even when relations between governments sour [1].

  • Values: Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam frames cooperation as a positive-sum effort, not zero-sum bargaining over security [1].

Limitations

  • Culture cannot settle cross-border terrorism. India keeps a firm line in the security track [4].
  • Geography is contested. Key nodes such as Gandhara, Kucha and Dunhuang [1] lie in Pakistan, Afghanistan and China. China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan have already jointly listed 33 Silk Road sites with UNESCO, and India is not part of that listing [6].
  • India's own base is thin. Over 1.19 crore manuscripts have been identified [5], but only about 8 lakh are digitised under Gyan Bharatam [7].
  • No institutional backing yet: the Forum has no secretariat, budget or meeting calendar, so it risks staying ceremonial.

Civilisational dialogue is therefore a complement to the SCO's security agenda, not a cure for it. It builds trust where the security track builds deterrence. The way forward:

  • a standing SCO working group with yearly targets for translations and exchanges;
  • priority digitisation of Buddhist, Persian and Sanskrit-mathematics collections;
  • heritage circuits that start with willing Central Asian partners.

This dual track, firm on terror and open on culture, reflects the Vedic call "Sangachhadhvam samvadadhvam" (move together, speak together) [1]. It also supports India's vision of the world as one family.

Sources

  1. 1PIB: Text of PM's address at the inauguration of the First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, Old Fort, Delhi (20 Nov 2026)Forum's date and venue, the transmission examples, the proposals, people-centric focus, Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and the Vedic verse *(the exact release page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*
  2. 2MEA: SCO brief (21 Aug 2025)and [MEA: India–SCO Cooperation](https://www.mea.gov.in/Portal/ForeignRelation/India-SCO_Cooperation.pdf) — SCO founded 2001, 10 members, Shared Buddhist Heritage pillar
  3. 3New India Samachar (PIB), 1–15 October 2025, p. 48PM proposed the Civilisational Dialogue Forum at the 25th SCO Summit, Tianjin
  4. 4PIB: "Every act of terrorism is criminal & unjustifiable…": Raksha Mantri at SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting, Qingdao (June 2025)India pressing the SCO on terrorism and its sponsors *(the exact release page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*
  5. 5PIB: Ministry of Culture press release on the Gyan Bharatam manuscript surveyover 1.19 crore manuscripts identified
  6. 6UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Silk Roads: the Routes Network of Chang'an–Tianshan Corridor33 sites listed jointly by China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan in 2014
  7. 7PIB Factsheet: Gyan Bharatam Missionabout 8 lakh manuscripts digitised *(the factsheet page could not be verified; linked to the PIB home page)*
Practice
7 questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on History