Despite three decades of the PC&PNDT Act, gender-biased sex selection persists. Examine the implementation gaps and suggest a mix of regulatory and social measures.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994 forbids using diagnostic technology to choose a child's sex [2]. Yet UNFPA estimates that about 4 lakh female births go missing each year, nearly 3% of all female births [3]. The law has slowed sex selection but not ended it, because weak enforcement meets deep-rooted son preference.
Implementation gaps
- Weak enforcers: At the 32nd Central Supervisory Board (CSB) meeting, States/UTs reported weak capacity in Appropriate Authorities, irregular inspections and slow follow-up on violations [1].
- No complainant: The doctor and the family both want sex disclosure kept secret. Clinic records and inspections are almost the only evidence, so weak audits mean few convictions.
- Technology moving faster than the law: The CSB stressed keeping the Act in step with a changing technology landscape [1].
- Deregulation risk: If the High-Level Committee on Non-Financial Regulatory Reforms recommendations [1] are applied without care, they could weaken the paperwork that makes detection possible.
- Enforcement not targeted: Sex selection clusters at the third birth after two daughters and in northern, western and central India [3]. Inspection effort does not reflect this.
- Demand left untouched: The Act controls supply, but son preference combined with falling fertility drives the skew [3].
Regulatory measures
- Risk-based inspections in districts with the worst sex ratios. MoHFW's digital processes [1] can flag clinics whose records look unusual.
- More staff and training for Appropriate Authorities, plus time-bound prosecution, so that inspections actually deter.
- Graded penalties: make clerical lapses easy to fix, but keep full punishment for revealing the foetus's sex.
- Sustained engagement with medical professionals as gatekeepers [1].
Social measures
- Link the Act with Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (MoWCD) [1], with outreach aimed at families that already have two daughters.
- Expand girls' education and women's employment so that daughters are valued economically.
- Build community participation and change mindsets so the girl child is valued [1].
The number of girls missing at birth fell to about 0.33 million a year in 2007–12, and UNFPA reports a declining trend [4]. This shows that law and programmes together do work. Sharper, risk-based enforcement combined with steady work on demand can close the remaining gap. That would advance the equality guaranteed by Articles 14–15 and the goals of SDG 5.
Sources
- 1Press Information Bureau: Union Health Minister chairs 32nd Central Supervisory Board meeting on the PC&PNDT Act (19 Nov 2026)Appropriate Authority capacity, inspections, follow-up, technology landscape, HLC recommendations, digital processes, medical professionals, BBBP convergence, community participation
- 2India Code: The Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994statutory prohibition on sex selection
- 3UNFPA India: Sex Ratio at Birth in India: Recent Trends and Patternsabout 4 lakh missing female births (~3%), third-birth and regional concentration, son preference with falling fertility
- 4UNFPA: How many girls are missing at birth in India?0.33 million girls missing per year in 2007–12; declining trend