·PIB·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityS&T

Evaluate the role of statutory supervisory bodies and Centre–State coordination in implementing social legislation, with reference to the Central Supervisory Board.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Role and strengths of statutory supervisory bodies
  2. Centre–State coordination: enabler and bottleneck

Social legislation usually fails in delivery, not in drafting. The PC&PNDT Act, 1994 [1] deals with about 4 lakh "missing" female births every year in India [2]. It does this through layers: the Central Supervisory Board (CSB) at the top and district Appropriate Authorities below. The CSB shows that supervisory bodies add real value, but only as far as Centre–State coordination allows.

Role and strengths of statutory supervisory bodies

  • Apex oversight: PIB has called the CSB the "highest body in the Government" overseeing the Act [3]. Its periodic reviews, including the 32nd meeting on 19 November 2026, keep the issue on the national agenda [4].
  • Keeping law current: The Board reviewed whether the Act keeps pace with changing diagnostic technology [4].
  • Convergence: It links the Act's supply-side controls with Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (MoWCD), which works on attitudes [4].
  • Results: Girls missing at birth fell from about 0.58 million to 0.33 million a year (2007–12). UNFPA links this fall to legal and programme measures [5].

Centre–State coordination: enabler and bottleneck

  • Forum for federal learning: Health is a State List subject. Through the CSB, States and UTs share good practices and plan targeted interventions [4].
  • Weak capacity: States reported that Appropriate Authorities lack capacity, inspections are irregular and violations are followed up slowly [4].
  • Dependent on States: The CSB reviews and advises, while inspections and cases depend on State machinery. Its directives therefore work only as well as each State's will.
  • Uneven geography: The skew is concentrated in northern and western States [5], so uniform national directives miss the hotspots.
  • Regulatory tension: The Board discussed the HLC on Non-Financial Regulatory Reforms [4]. Easing compliance could weaken clinic records, which are often the only evidence of a hidden crime.
  • Limits of law: Son preference combined with falling fertility drives demand [5]. No supervisory body can regulate that.

Overall, the CSB works well as an agenda-setter and coordinating forum. Its impact is limited by State enforcement capacity and by social attitudes. The way forward:

  • Target inspections at high-skew districts using MoHFW's digital processes [4].
  • Train Appropriate Authorities and make them accountable.
  • In any regulatory easing, separate clerical lapses from actual sex determination.
  • Deepen convergence with BBBP.

This kind of cooperative federalism would advance SDG 5 and the constitutional promise of equality under Articles 14 and 15.

Sources

  1. 1India Code: The Pre-conception and Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994: statute and its institutional framework
  2. 2UNFPA India: gender-biased sex selection: about 4 lakh female births missing each year
  3. 3PIB Archive: release on the 7th CSB meeting, 3 April 2002: CSB described as the "highest body in the Government" overseeing the Act
  4. 4PIB: 32nd Meeting of the Central Supervisory Board under the PC&PNDT Act, 19 November 2026: technology review, HLC recommendations, Appropriate Authority capacity, inspections, digital initiatives, BBBP convergence, State good practices
  5. 5UNFPA India: How Many Girls Are Missing at Birth in India? Trends in Sex Ratio at Birth (2001–12): decline from 0.58 to 0.33 million a year, northern/western concentration, son preference with falling fertility
Practice
8 questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography