·PIB·15 marks·250–350 wordsEconomyEnvironmentIR

Discuss the significance of recognising scientific assessments from developing countries alongside IPCC reports in global climate governance.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Significance
  2. Concerns to address

The Global Stocktake (GST) under Article 14 of the Paris Agreement is the world's five-yearly check on how far it has got with climate action. Its second cycle (GST-2) began at COP31 in Antalya and will end in 2028 [2]. At the launch, India asked that scientific assessments from developing countries be recognised alongside IPCC reports [1]. This is a demand about whose evidence shapes the global climate agenda.

Significance

  • Equity in knowledge: The evidence behind global targets should reflect the conditions and research of the Global South. India wants GST-2 grounded in best available science, equity and CBDR-RC [1].
  • Capturing local impacts and adaptation: Southern assessments may record local damage and adaptation costs that global syntheses under-count. UNEP estimates developing countries need about USD 305 bn/yr for adaptation by 2035. Even if international public flows triple, they would cover only 20–29% of that need [4].
  • A true "360-degree" stocktake: GST-1 found the world not on track and found support falling short of developing-country needs [3]. Southern evidence strengthens scrutiny of means of implementation (finance, technology and capacity-building), not just emission cuts [1].
  • Legitimacy and ownership: The GST outcome guides how Parties update their NDCs [1]. When countries see their own evidence in the findings, they are more likely to accept them and act on them.
  • Climate justice: It amplifies the countries least responsible for emissions but most exposed to their effects. This fits India's position that historically responsible nations must lead [5].

Concerns to address

  • Comparability and quality: Different methods and review standards could dilute the IPCC's consensus authority.
  • Politicisation: National studies could be used selectively to justify lower ambition.
  • Capacity gaps: Many developing countries lack the funding and data systems to produce rigorous assessments.
  • Process strain: In GST-1, negotiators had to ask for enough time for the "consideration of outputs" stage [6]. More inputs would add to that pressure.

Recognising Southern science should complement the IPCC, not compete with it. The way forward is to agree common quality criteria, fund regional science partnerships and capacity-building, and feed these assessments into GST-2's technical assessment. An inclusive evidence base would make the stocktake fairer and more credible, in line with equity, CBDR-RC and SDG 13.

Sources

  1. 1PIB, India's statement on the Second Global Stocktake at the COP31 High-Level Event, Antalya (18 Nov 2026)developing-country science alongside the IPCC; 360-degree view; equity and CBDR-RC; means of implementation; GST outcome informs NDCs. The exact release page could not be verified, so this links to the PIB domain root.
  2. 2UNFCCC, The second global stocktakeGST-2 runs from CMA 8 (Nov 2026) to CMA 10 (Nov 2028); Article 14 basis.
  3. 3UNFCCC, Outcome of the first global stocktakethe world is not on track; support falls short of developing-country needs.
  4. 4UNEP, Executive Director's media statement on the Adaptation Gap Report 2026USD 305 bn/yr adaptation need by 2035; tripled public flows cover only 20–29%.
  5. 5PIB, COP28 National Statement by Shri Bhupender Yadav (2023)equity and climate justice; developed countries must lead.
  6. 6UNFCCC, Draft text on CMA agenda item 4: First global stocktakerequest for adequate time for the consideration-of-outputs stage.
Practice
7 questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Economy