The Global Stocktake is the accountability engine of the Paris Agreement, yet it risks becoming mitigation-centric. Examine India's demand for a '360-degree' Second Global Stocktake.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Global Stocktake (GST) comes from Article 14 of the Paris Agreement. Every five years it reviews collective progress and guides how countries update their NDCs and the support they give [2]. When GST-2 (covering 2024–2028) opened at COP31, Antalya, India asked for a "360-degree" stocktake. This would judge whether developed countries delivered support as strictly as it judges emission cuts [1].
Why the GST risks becoming mitigation-centric
- GST-1 (decision 1/CMA.5) found that countries were not collectively on track on mitigation, adaptation and support [3]. But emissions are easy to measure, so they dominate the headline messages.
- Adaptation stays out of view: international public adaptation finance was only USD 26 bn in 2023. Needs are 12–14 times larger [6].
- Finance accounting is disputed: India objects to counting multilateral development bank (MDB) flows towards the USD 300 bn NCQG. Developing countries are MDB shareholders too, so their own money would be counted as support from developed countries [5].
Elements of India's demand [1]
- Scope: assess achievements and gaps, including updated NDCs, Biennial Transparency Reports, Article 6 cooperation, the Global Goal on Adaptation and the Just Transition Mechanism.
- Accountability on means of implementation: India says finance and technology transfer have fallen "far below" what developed countries are obliged to provide.
- Process and principles: an open, transparent and inclusive process, grounded in equity and CBDR-RC.
- Science: assessments from developing countries to be used alongside IPCC reports.
Assessment
- Strength: the duty is legally clear. Under the Paris Agreement, developed countries provide finance, so the NCQG "is not an investment goal" [4].
- Strength: the headline number needs scrutiny. The OECD reports USD 136.7 bn in 2024, but this includes USD 30.5 bn of mobilised private finance [7].
- Limitation: public budgets alone cannot reach the USD 1.3 tn call. A genuine 360-degree view must also examine India's own updated NDC, which India itself listed for assessment [1].
Overall, India's demand turns the GST from a check on developing countries' ambition into a two-way test of whether ambition is matched by support. GST-2 should report grants, loans and private flows separately. It should also settle the NCQG baseline before its final stage and include science from the Global South. A balanced stocktake grounded in CBDR-RC would make climate justice measurable and move the world closer to SDG 13.
Sources
- 1PIB press release: India's statement on the Second Global Stocktake at the COP31 High-Level Event, Antalya (18 Nov 2026)360-degree view; means of implementation "far below" obligations; areas GST-2 should assess; equity/CBDR-RC; developing-country science alongside IPCC; updated NDCs. *(Links to the PIB home page because the exact release page could not be found in search.)*
- 2UNFCCC: Global StocktakeArticle 14 basis; five-year cycle; GST-2 covers 2024–2028; outcome guides updating of NDCs and support
- 3UNFCCC: Outcome of the First Global Stocktakedecision 1/CMA.5; Parties not collectively on track on mitigation, adaptation and support
- 4PIB: India's statement for LMDC at the High-Level Ministerial on Climate Finance, COP29NCQG "is not an investment goal"; developed countries provide and mobilise finance
- 5PIB: Government reply on the NCQG outcome of COP29objection to counting MDB flows towards the USD 300 bn goal
- 6UNEP: Adaptation Gap Report 2025USD 26 bn public adaptation finance in 2023; gap 12–14 times current flows
- 7OECD: Developed countries exceed USD 100 billion climate finance goal for third consecutive year (May 2026)USD 136.7 bn in 2024, including USD 30.5 bn mobilised private finance