·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolitySociety

Evaluate the Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023 as a tool for substantive rather than formal equality, in light of its commencement conditions.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Design features that favour substantive equality
  2. Commencement conditions and gaps that keep it formal

Formal equality gives women the same rights on paper. Substantive equality asks whether women actually get power, access and voice. Justice B.V. Nagarathna recently warned that women holding high office do not prove equality for all women [1]. The 106th Amendment is built to deliver substantive equality, but its commencement conditions keep it formal for now.

Design features that favour substantive equality

  • Changes the institution, not just a few faces: "as nearly as may be" one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha, State Assemblies and Delhi Assembly are reserved for women [2]. This moves women from voters to decision-makers [1].
  • Reaches women facing caste exclusion: one-third of SC/ST-reserved seats go to SC/ST women [2], so caste-based exclusion within gender is addressed.
  • Lasting but open to review: the reservation runs for 15 years and Parliament can extend it [2]. This is affirmative action in the spirit of Article 15(3).

Commencement conditions and gaps that keep it formal

  • A right that has not started: under Article 334A, reservation begins only after the first Census published after the Act and a delimitation based on it, with no fixed date [2]. A right granted in 2023 has not yet given a single woman a seat.
  • Timing left to the government: PRS warns that the 2026 Delimitation Bills may let the government decide when delimitation happens and which Census it uses [4]. Commencement therefore becomes uncertain, not guaranteed.
  • Rotation after every delimitation may reduce MPs' incentive to work for their constituencies [3], so women cannot build a lasting political base.
  • Uneven coverage: there is no OBC women sub-quota, and the Rajya Sabha and Legislative Councils are excluded [3]. The benefits may go mostly to elite women.
  • Wider exclusion remains: about 35–40 million women were "missing" from the labour force in 2012 [5]. Seats in legislatures alone cannot fix economic exclusion.

Verdict The Act is necessary but not sufficient. Its design aims at substantive equality, but in practice it stays formal until it actually starts and reaches women outside the elite.

Overall, the Amendment's promise depends on when it starts and how far it reaches. Parliament could turn it into real change by fixing a commencement date in law, reviewing seat rotation before the first cycle, debating an OBC sub-quota, and setting candidate norms within parties. That would bring it closer to Article 14's guarantee of equality and SDG 5 (gender equality).

Sources

  1. 1The Hindu: "Women are yet to achieve substantive equality: SC judge" (20 Nov 2026), news reportJustice Nagarathna on high office vs substantive equality; women as decision-makers *(exact article page could not be verified; domain root linked)*
  2. 2PRS Legislative Research: Women's Reservation Bill 2023, Constitution (128th Amendment) Bill, Bill Trackone-third quantum, coverage, SC/ST sub-quota, 15-year term, Census-plus-delimitation trigger
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research: Issues to Consider: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023rotation reduces incentive; no OBC sub-quota; Rajya Sabha and Councils excluded
  4. 4PRS Legislative Research: Delimitation Bills of 2026, Issues for Considerationgovernment discretion over when delimitation happens and which Census it uses
  5. 5World Bank: India: Women, Work and Employment35–40 million women missing from the labour force in 2012
Practice
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity