Judicial pronouncements and legislation alone cannot secure gender justice. Discuss the gaps in implementation and suggest measures.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
India's legal framework already gives women formal equality. It rests on Article 15(3), the Vishaka judgment, the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and the 106th Amendment. But in her Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture (2026), Justice B.V. Nagarathna warned that a law fails when remedies are out of reach, authorities do not act, or social attitudes stop women from claiming their rights [1]. Substantive equality therefore depends on how laws are delivered, not only on what they declare.
Gaps in implementation
- Delayed rights: The 106th Amendment's one-third reservation begins only after a post-Act Census and delimitation. Neither has a fixed date, so a right granted in 2023 has not yet produced a single reserved seat [2][3].
- Gaps in the law's design: There is no OBC women sub-quota, and the Rajya Sabha and Legislative Councils are excluded. Reserved seats also rotate after each delimitation, which may weaken an MP's incentive to work for the constituency [3].
- Weak frontline machinery: Rights depend on protection officers, police and revenue officials. When these authorities do not act, guarantees under the Domestic Violence Act or the POSH Act become empty [1].
- Economic exclusion: Indian women lost jobs between 2005 and 2012 even as growth continued [4]. Despite equal inheritance rights since 2005, only about 11.6% of households have women who own agricultural land [5].
- Social attitudes and intersectionality: Gains made by elite women do not reach women held back by caste, class or region [1].
Measures
- Legislative: Set a time-bound Census–delimitation schedule. Review seat rotation, since a Ministry of Panchayati Raj study found that few women were re-elected after their seats were de-reserved [3].
- Administrative: States should fill and train protection officers and POSH Internal Committees, and expand One Stop Centres and gender-sensitisation of the police.
- Economic: Promote joint land titling. PLFS/MoSPI should report paid, secure and self-owned work separately from total participation [5].
- Social and legal: Run legal-literacy drives through Legal Services Authorities, and campaigns that change attitudes towards inheritance and reporting violence.
- Inclusive design: Consider sub-quotas so that reservation reaches women outside the elite [3].
Judgments and laws set only the minimum standard. Real gender justice needs institutions that work, timelines that hold, and women's economic ownership. Turning formal rights into lived outcomes would fulfil the constitutional promise of equality under Articles 14 and 15 and advance SDG 5, moving women from rights-holders to decision-makers.
Sources
- 1Women are yet to achieve substantive equality: SC judge, The Hindu (20 Nov 2026)the judge's conditions for laws to work (reachable remedies, authorities that act, changed attitudes); frontline authorities; intersectionality
- 2PRS Legislative Research, Bill Summary: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023one-third quota; start only after Census and delimitation
- 3PRS Legislative Research, Issues to Consider: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023commencement lag; no OBC sub-quota; Rajya Sabha and Councils excluded; effect of rotation on MPs; Panchayati Raj study on re-election
- 4World Bank, India: Women, Work and Employmentwomen lost jobs between 2005 and 2012 despite growth
- 5World Bank, Women in the Indian Agricultural Sector: Enhancing Economic Outcomesabout 11.6% of households have women owning agricultural land (NFHS); PLFS data on women's work