·The Hindu

Women are yet to achieve substantive equality: SC judge

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12-18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Why the 2023 Promise Has Not Reached Parliament Yet
  9. The Lecture's Own Puzzle: Is a Quota Formal or Real Equality?
  10. Where the Gap Shows: Women's Work
  11. Who Must Act on the Judge's Three Conditions
  12. Anchors for Answers
  13. Mains Relevance
  14. Related Topics to Study Next
  15. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  16. Common Errors / Trap Areas
Practice
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

1. At a Glance

  • Core idea: Having women in high office is not proof that equality exists across society. Substantive equality asks whether women actually get access to education, jobs, property and legal remedies. Formal equality only asks whether the law gives them the same rights on paper [1].
  • Speaker: Justice B.V. Nagarathna is one of the senior-most Supreme Court judges and is in line to become India's first woman Chief Justice of India [1].
  • Main argument: A court judgment or a new law cannot change reality on its own. It also needs remedies that people can reach, public authorities that act, and social attitudes that change [1].
  • Why it matters for UPSC: It links the Women's Reservation Act, 2023 (106th Amendment), Supreme Court gender rulings, gender justice and constitutional morality. It is useful for GS-I, GS-II and GS-IV, and for Essay.

2. Why in the News

  • Justice Nagarathna gave the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Somerville College, University of Oxford, on Wednesday, 18 November 2026. The Hindu reported it on 20 November 2026 (page 4, International edition) [1].
  • She said: "A woman may hold a senior position while other women remain excluded from education, employment, property, or effective legal remedies." [1]
  • She said only the practice of substantive equality can deal with the differences among women who come from and live through different life experiences [1].
  • She cited the Constitutional amendments that give women one-third of seats in Parliament and State legislatures as proof that women should take part in decision-making, not just hold a formal right to vote [1].

3. Background & Evolution

  • Formal equality treats everyone the same in law. Substantive equality looks at historical exclusion and at actual outcomes. The judge described historical exclusion as shaping how institutions are made up [1].
  • Milestones for women in legislatures:
  • 19 Sep 2023: The Constitution (128th Amendment) Bill, 2023 (the Women's Reservation Bill) was introduced in Lok Sabha [4].
  • The Bill was enacted as the Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023, also called Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam. It reserves "as nearly as may be" one-third of seats for women in the Lok Sabha, State Legislative Assemblies and the Delhi Legislative Assembly [2].
  • Reservation starts only after delimitation based on the first Census published after the Act commences [2][3].

  • Earlier efforts: Women's reservation bills were introduced several times before 2023. PRS notes these earlier attempts in its analysis [3].

  • Namesake: The lecture honours Cornelia Sorabji, a pioneering Indian woman lawyer. The lecture being held at Somerville College suggests an Oxford link [1]. (Biographical details are not in the sources and should be checked.)

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Speaker Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Supreme Court of India; in line to be first woman CJI [1]
Event Inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture, Somerville College, Oxford [1]
Key concept Substantive equality: real access to education, employment, property and legal remedies [1]
Related law Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023; introduced as the 128th Amendment Bill [2][4]
Quantum "As nearly as may be" one-third of seats [2]
Bodies covered Lok Sabha, State Legislative Assemblies, Delhi Legislative Assembly [2]
SC/ST sub-quota One-third of seats already reserved for SCs/STs go to women from those groups [2]
Commencement After delimitation that follows the first Census published after the Act [2]
Duration 15 years, extendable by Parliament [2]
Rotation Reserved seats rotate after each delimitation [2]
Not covered Rajya Sabha and State Legislative Councils [3]

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Legal / Constitutional

  • A judgment alone cannot make every workplace safe, get every girl into school, secure every woman's lawful inheritance, or protect every domestic violence victim in time [1].
  • A law does not achieve its purpose if remedies are out of reach, authorities fail to act, or social attitudes stop women from claiming their rights [1].
  • The 106th Amendment's dependence on Census and delimitation creates an implementation lag between when the right is granted and when it takes effect [2][3].

Social

  • Intersectionality: Women differ by class, caste, region and life experience. A gain for elite women does not reach everyone [1].
  • Sub-quota debate: The Act has a sub-quota for SC/ST women but none for OBC women [2][3].

Governance / Political

  • Political representation moves women from voters to decision-makers [1].
  • Seat rotation can weaken a representative's link with their constituency and their incentive to nurture it [3].

Ethical (GS-IV)

  • The gap between formal and substantive equality is a question of constitutional morality and of state duty to act affirmatively, not only to stay neutral [1].
  • Changing social attitudes is presented as a condition for rights to work in practice [1].

Administrative

  • Rights depend on frontline institutions: police, protection officers and revenue authorities for inheritance. When public authorities fail to act, legal guarantees become empty [1].

6. Recent Developments (last 12-18 months)

  • 18 Nov 2026: Justice Nagarathna gave the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Oxford [1].
  • 2026: The Hindu's site listed "Delimitation" among its trending topics on the date of the report. This points to an ongoing debate about delimitation, which also decides when women's reservation starts [1][2].
  • No other dated developments could be verified from whitelisted sources.

7. Prelims Hooks

  • The Women's Reservation Bill was introduced as the Constitution (128th Amendment) Bill, 2023 and enacted as the 106th Amendment Act [4][2].
  • Lok Sabha introduction date: 19 September 2023 [4].
  • Reservation quantum: "as nearly as may be" one-third of seats [2].
  • It applies to the Lok Sabha, State Assemblies and the Delhi Legislative Assembly [2].
  • It does not apply to the Rajya Sabha or State Legislative Councils [3].
  • One-third of SC/ST-reserved seats are reserved for SC/ST women [2].
  • There is no separate OBC women sub-quota [2][3].
  • Reservation lasts 15 years, and Parliament can extend it [2].
  • It starts after delimitation following the first Census published after commencement [2].
  • Reserved seats rotate after each delimitation [2].
  • The Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture was first held at Somerville College, Oxford, and delivered by Justice B.V. Nagarathna [1].
  • Justice B.V. Nagarathna is in line to be India's first woman CJI [1].

8. Why the 2023 Promise Has Not Reached Parliament Yet

  • The right exists on paper, but the start date depends on two other events
  • The reservation starts only after the first Census published after the Act, and then a delimitation (redrawing constituency boundaries) based on that Census [2][3].
  • Neither event has a fixed date in the Act. So the law sets no deadline for women to actually get the seats.
  • This is the judge's point in a real case. The right was granted in 2023, but no woman has yet won a reserved seat under it [1][2].

  • The government may now change the rule that sets the start date

  • Down to Earth reported in 2026 that the government plans to amend Article 334A, the provision added by the 106th Amendment, so that delimitation can use the 2011 Census [5].
  • If this happens, the start could come earlier. But constituencies would then be drawn using population data that is 15 or more years old.
  • This comes from one press report. Check it against the official Bill text before you quote it.

  • How often reserved seats move matters for how much a woman MP can do

  • PRS notes that after 2026, delimitation must follow every Census. So reserved seats would move roughly every 10 years [3].
  • PRS also warns that moving seats may reduce an MP's incentive to work for their constituency, because the seat may not be reserved, or winnable, next time [3].
  • So a woman can win a seat but may not be able to keep it. She becomes a decision-maker for a term, not long enough to build a lasting political base.

9. The Lecture's Own Puzzle: Is a Quota Formal or Real Equality?

  • The strongest objection, built from the judge's own logic
  • The judge says one woman in high office does not prove equality for all women [1].
  • Then one-third women in Parliament is also, on that logic, "more women in high office". Critics can say the 106th Amendment is formal equality on a larger scale, and the women who gain will mostly be those who already have money, caste standing or political families.

  • What is right about this objection

  • The Act gives a sub-quota (a reserved share inside the reserved share) to SC/ST women, but none to OBC women [2][3]. So it partly answers the point that women differ by caste, and partly ignores it.
  • The Act does not cover the Rajya Sabha or the Legislative Councils, where members are chosen through parties and legislators, not by direct vote [3]. Party leaders, mostly men, still decide who goes there.

  • Why the objection does not fully win

  • One woman judge is a single appointment. A quota changes who makes up the legislature in every election, in a fixed share of seats. That changes the institution itself, which is the judge's own reason for supporting it [1].
  • She says women must move from voters to decision-makers [1]. The sub-quota shows the law can be designed to reach women who have been excluded for a long time. The fair conclusion is that the quota is necessary but not enough on its own.

  • How to write this in Mains

  • Do not call the Act "substantive equality achieved". Call it a structural tool that becomes substantive only if it reaches women outside the elite, and only if it actually comes into force [2][3].

10. Where the Gap Shows: Women's Work

  • Women left the workforce even while the economy grew
  • The World Bank studied five National Sample Survey rounds from 1993-94 to 2011-12. It found that rural female labour force participation (the share of women working or looking for work) fell over that period [6].
  • It estimated that about 35 to 40 million women were "missing" from the labour force in 2012, compared with the earlier growth trend of 1999-2005 [6].
  • This matches the judge's list. Employment is one of the four areas where she says women remain excluded [1].

  • The recent rise in women's work is not all good news

  • A later World Bank paper using PLFS (Periodic Labour Force Survey) data finds that women's share of farm labour has risen while men's has fallen [7].
  • But women are more likely to be casual labourers (paid daily, with no job security) or unpaid workers on family land [7].
  • So more women are counted as "working", but many earn nothing of their own and do not own the land they work on. A higher participation number can hide the very exclusion from property and income that the judge described [1][7].

  • Why this links to inheritance law

  • The 2005 amendment gave daughters equal rights in family property on paper. If women still work family land without owning it, then this is the judge's "law on paper, no change in fact" problem [1][7].

11. Who Must Act on the Judge's Three Conditions

  • The judge's three conditions are remedies people can reach, authorities that act, and attitudes that change [1]. Each one has a named actor.
  • Parliament and the Union Government should give a firm start date for women's reservation
  • At present the start depends on a Census and a delimitation that have no fixed date [2][3].
  • A date written into law, or a Census and delimitation timeline announced in advance, would turn a promise into a right women can count on.

  • Parliament should look again at seat rotation, which PRS raised as a concern

  • PRS flagged that moving reserved seats about every 10 years may weaken MPs' link with their constituency [3].
  • Parliament should study how long women stay in politics after their reserved seat moves, before the first rotation takes place.

  • State governments must staff the frontline

  • The judge says rights fail when public authorities do not act [1]. Protection officers under the domestic violence law and revenue officials who record inheritance are state-level posts.
  • States, not courts, decide whether these posts are filled and trained. A Supreme Court judgment cannot do it for them [1].

  • Labour policy should track the quality of women's work, not just the headcount

  • World Bank evidence shows the rise in women's work is mostly casual and unpaid farm work [7].
  • The Labour Ministry and MoSPI (Ministry of Statistics) should report paid, secure and self-owned work separately. Then progress means real income, not just being counted as working.

12. Anchors for Answers

  • Data: About 35–40 million women "missing" from India's labour force in 2012 compared with the 1999–2005 trend; rural female participation fell from 1993-94 to 2011-12 (World Bank) [6]
  • Data: Women's share of farm labour is rising, but mostly as casual and unpaid workers (World Bank, PLFS data) [7]
  • Report/Committee: PRS Legislative Research, Issues to Consider: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023. It found rotation about every 10 years and a weaker incentive to serve the constituency [3]
  • Report/Committee: World Bank, India: Women, Work and Employment [6]
  • Law/Case: Article 15(3) (special provisions for women); Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023, which inserted Article 334A tying the start to Census plus delimitation [2][5]; Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005

13. Mains Relevance

14. Related Topics to Study Next

  • Articles 14, 15(3) and 16: the constitutional basis for equality and for special provisions for women.
  • 73rd/74th Amendments: an earlier model of women's reservation in local bodies, useful for comparison with the 106th Amendment.
  • Delimitation and Census: these decide when women's reservation starts.
  • Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005: inheritance rights, which the judge named as a substantive gap.
  • Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005: an example of the gap between law and access to remedies.
  • POSH Act, 2013 / Vishaka guidelines: workplace safety, which the judge said a judgment alone cannot guarantee.
  • Women in the judiciary: representation on the bench and the first woman CJI.

15. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Substantive equality (Polity): The lecture's central idea: equality judged by real access to education, jobs, property and remedies, not just rights on paper.
  • Formal equality (Polity): The contrast concept: equal rights in law alone, which the judge says is not enough.
  • 106th Constitutional Amendment Act 2023 (Polity): The women's reservation law the judge cited; know its one-third quota, coverage, 15-year term and commencement.
  • Delimitation (Polity): Women's reservation starts only after delimitation, so this decides when the law takes effect.
  • Constitutional morality (Polity): The gap between legal and real equality is framed as a question of upholding the Constitution's spirit.
  • Intersectionality (Polity): Explains why women differ by caste, class and region, so gains for some do not reach all.
  • Women's reservation in local bodies (Polity): The earlier model of women's reservation, useful for comparison with the 106th Amendment.
  • Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005 (Polity): Inheritance rights, which the judge named as an area where law and reality can diverge.
  • Vishaka case (Polity): Landmark judgment on workplace harassment; shows what a judgment can and cannot achieve alone.
  • Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act 2013 (Polity): Law that replaced the Vishaka guidelines; an example of a workplace safety law needing enforcement.
  • Rajya Sabha (Polity): The Act does not cover the Rajya Sabha, a common Prelims trap.
  • Reserved constituencies (Polity): The SC/ST sub-quota for women sits inside these reserved seats; there is no OBC sub-quota.
  • Chief Justice of India (Polity): The speaker is in line to become the first woman CJI, which the note ties to representation.

16. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Bill number vs Act number: It was introduced as the 128th Amendment Bill and enacted as the 106th Amendment Act [4][2]. Do not mix up the two.
  • Coverage: The Act covers the Delhi Assembly, but not the Rajya Sabha or Legislative Councils [2][3].
  • Commencement: The reservation is not yet in force on enactment. It depends on Census and delimitation [2].
  • OBC sub-quota: There is none. Only SC/ST women have a sub-quota [2][3].
  • Formal vs substantive equality: Having a woman CJI or woman legislators is an example of formal representation, not evidence of substantive equality. This was the judge's central point [1].

Sources

  1. 1"Women are yet to achieve substantive equality: SC judge", Krishnadas Rajagopal, The Hindu (20 Nov 2026, p. 4, International edition)thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2PRS Legislative Research, Bill Summary: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023prsindia.org · tier 1
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research, Issues to Consider: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023prsindia.org · tier 1
  4. 4PRS Bill Track: The Constitution (One Hundred Twenty-Eighth Amendment) Bill, 2023prsindia.org · tier 1
  5. 5Women's Reservation Act: How India is amending its own amendment (Down To Earth)downtoearth.org.in · tier 4
  6. 6India: Women, Work and Employment (World Bank Open Knowledge Repository)openknowledge.worldbank.org · tier 2
  7. 7World Bank document P177653: women's labour in Indian agriculture using PLFS datadocuments1.worldbank.org · tier 2
At the end · practice MCQs
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

Mains Q&A on this note

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 20 November

All 20 November articles →