Judgments and legislation alone cannot secure gender justice without accessible remedies and responsive institutions. Discuss with examples.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
In her inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture (November 2026), Justice B.V. Nagarathna observed that a judgment "cannot by itself guarantee" safe workplaces, lawful inheritance or timely protection for women [1]. Laws give women formal equality. Women reach substantive equality only when every link from law to remedy works.
What judgments and legislation achieve
- Norm-setting: The Vishaka (1997) guidelines led to the POSH Act, 2013, which requires Internal Committees and district-level Local Committees [2].
- Creating rights: The PWDVA, 2005 gives women protection orders and the right to reside in the shared household [3]. The 2005 HSA amendment made daughters coparceners, a right Vineeta Sharma (2020) affirmed.
- Constitutional basis: Art. 15(3) allows special measures for women.
Where rights break before reaching women
- Inaccessible remedies: Distance, cost and lack of legal awareness keep courts out of reach. The judge said legislation "fails its purpose" when remedies are inaccessible [1].
- Unresponsive institutions: A Protection Officer who also holds other duties, or a workplace committee that exists only on paper, leaves a strong law unused. In her words, laws fail when "public authorities fail to act" [1].
- Social attitudes: Daughters often give up their inheritance under family pressure despite Vineeta Sharma. Social norms stop women from claiming rights that exist [1].
- Economic exclusion: Female LFPR rose from 23.3% (2017-18) to 41.7% (2023-24), but this is still well below the 60.1% for all persons [4]. Much of the work is unpaid family help, so women are counted as working without equal access to employment.
- Presence vs power: One-third reservation in Panchayats (Art. 243D) brought women into office, but "sarpanch-pati" proxy rule shows that holding a seat is not the same as holding power.
Way forward
- States should appoint full-time, trained Protection Officers, check that POSH committees exist, and measure success by cases resolved on time.
- Legal aid camps in villages under Art. 39A/NALSA can take remedies to women.
- PLFS should report paid and unpaid work separately.
- Elected women should get training before the 106th Amendment quota starts.
Judgments and laws set the standard, but institutions decide what women actually receive. Accessible legal aid, accountable officials and changing social attitudes can turn the guarantees of Articles 14, 15 and 39 into lived reality and advance SDG 5.
Sources
- 1Women in high public office doesn't mean equality throughout society: Justice Nagarathna, *The Hindu* (19 Nov 2026)"judgment cannot by itself guarantee"; legislation fails when remedies are inaccessible, authorities don't act, or social attitudes block women
- 2Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 — India CodeInternal and Local Committees
- 3Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 — India Codeprotection orders, right to reside in shared household
- 4MoSPI Press Note: PLFS Annual Report, July 2023–June 2024female LFPR 23.3% → 41.7%; 60.1% for all persons
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.