·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolitySociety

Thirty years of one-third reservation in local bodies hold lessons for implementing the 106th Amendment. Evaluate.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Lessons of success
  2. Lessons of limitation
  3. Transferability to the 106th Amendment

The 73rd/74th Amendments (1992–93) reserved at least one-third of seats and chairperson posts in Panchayats and Municipalities for women (Art. 243D/243T). The 106th Amendment (2023) extends one-third reservation to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies. It takes effect only after the next census and delimitation [1]. Local-body quotas offer a useful but imperfect template.

Lessons of success

  • Critical mass: lakhs of women entered public office, and several states later raised the local quota to 50%. This shows that quotas create a leadership pipeline.
  • Legitimacy of representation: Justice Nagarathna cited the amendments giving women one-third of seats as a constitutional tool for inclusion [4].
  • Judicial and executive follow-up: a Supreme Court direction led the Ministry of Panchayati Raj (MoPR) to set up an advisory committee on proxy participation. Its 2025 report proposed penalties, training and mentoring networks [2].

Lessons of limitation

  • Proxy rule: the "pradhan-pati" practice persists, rooted in patriarchal norms and inadequate training [2].
  • Presence ≠ power: a woman in high office does not mean equality across society. Rights fail when remedies are inaccessible or authorities do not act [4].
  • Weak economic spillover: female LFPR rose to 41.7% (2023-24), still well below the 60.1% rate for all persons [3]. Political quotas alone have not delivered economic agency.
  • Rotation: reserved seats change every term, so women cannot easily build up an incumbency. The 106th Amendment also rotates seats, after each delimitation [1].

Transferability to the 106th Amendment

  • Where the analogy holds: the same social barriers will apply. Family gatekeeping may give way to party gatekeeping over tickets.
  • Where it breaks: legislative seats are larger and costlier to contest. The quota excludes the Rajya Sabha and Legislative Councils, has no OBC sub-quota, and depends on delimitation [1]. These gaps were absent or smaller at the local level.

On balance, local-body reservation has proved that quotas widen access, but it has also shown that access does not by itself bring authority. Before delimitation, India should run training for women aspirants, make parties set internal nomination norms, apply the MoPR committee's anti-proxy measures [2], and track women's economic outcomes [3]. Done this way, the 106th Amendment can move from formal to substantive equality under Art. 15(3) and advance SDG 5.5 on women's leadership.

Sources

  1. 1PRS Legislative Research – Bill Summary: The Constitution (128th Amendment) Bill, 2023 (Women's Reservation Bill)one-third reservation in Lok Sabha/State Assemblies; start after census and delimitation; rotation after each delimitation; no Rajya Sabha/Council or OBC sub-quota
  2. 2Ministry of Panchayati Raj – Advisory Committee Report, "Transforming Women's Representation and Roles in Panchayati Raj Systems and Institutions: Eliminating Efforts for Proxy Participation" (2025)Supreme Court-directed committee; proxy participation; patriarchal norms and training gaps; penalties and mentoring recommended
  3. 3MoSPI – Press Note, PLFS Annual Report July 2023–June 2024female LFPR 41.7% vs 60.1% for all persons (2023-24)
  4. 4The Hindu – "Women in high public office doesn't mean equality throughout society: Justice Nagarathna" (19 Nov 2026, news report)one-third seat amendments; high office ≠ societal equality; inaccessible remedies and inactive authorities
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity