"The mere presence of women in high public office does not establish equality throughout society." Critically examine with reference to substantive equality in the Indian Constitution.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
At the first Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Oxford in November 2026, Justice B.V. Nagarathna spoke about women in public office. She is in line to be India's first woman CJI. She warned that one woman may hold a senior post while other women remain shut out of education, jobs, property and legal remedies [1]. The statement largely holds. A woman in visible office reflects formal equality, while the Constitution aims at substantive equality.
Substantive equality in the Constitution
- Art. 14 guarantees equality before law, which is formal equality. Art. 15(3) allows special provisions for women because their disadvantages are built into social structures.
- The Directive Principles add Art. 39(d) (equal pay), Art. 42 (maternity relief) and Art. 39A (free legal aid). Under Art. 51A(e), citizens have a duty to respect women's dignity.
Where presence does advance equality
- Political voice: The 73rd and 74th Amendments (Art. 243D/243T) reserved one-third of local-body seats for women. The 106th Amendment extends this quota to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies [2].
- Agenda-setting: Women judges and sarpanches serve as role models. The judge herself cited the amendments that reserve one-third of seats [1].
- Shaping norms: The judiciary's Vishaka (1997) guidelines led to the POSH Act, 2013.
Why presence does not establish equality
- Elite filter: Women who reach the top are often already advantaged. The judge stressed that differences among women call for tailored action [1].
- Economic exclusion: Female labour force participation (LFPR) rose from 23.3% in 2017-18 to 41.7% in 2023-24. It still trails the overall rate of 60.1% [3], and much of this work is unpaid family work.
- Implementation gap: A judgment cannot by itself guarantee safe workplaces, lawful inheritance or timely protection from domestic violence. Laws fail when remedies are out of reach or authorities do not act [1].
- Social attitudes: Daughters gained coparcenary rights under the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, but family pressure often makes them give these up [1].
- Presence vs power: Proxy rule by male relatives (the "sarpanch-pati") shows that holding office is not the same as holding authority.
Representation is necessary but not sufficient, and equality should be measured by what reaches the last woman. The way forward has four steps:
- staff Protection Officers and POSH Internal Committees;
- take NALSA legal aid to villages;
- report the quality of women's work in the PLFS;
- train elected women before the 106th Amendment quota begins.
Only then will the promise of Art. 15(3) and SDG-5 reach every village panchayat, not just the people at the top.
Sources
- 1Women in high public office doesn't mean equality throughout society: Justice Nagarathna, *The Hindu* (19 Nov 2026)Oxford lecture statements: exclusion from education, jobs, property and remedies; differences among women; limits of judgments; failure of authorities and social attitudes; reference to one-third seat amendments
- 2Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam aims to increase women's representation in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies, News On AIR (Prasar Bharati)106th Amendment's one-third reservation in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies
- 3Press Note: Annual Report, Periodic Labour Force Survey (July 2023 – June 2024), MoSPIfemale LFPR of 23.3% (2017-18) and 41.7% (2023-24); overall LFPR of 60.1%