Should foreign policy be insulated from partisan politics in a parliamentary democracy? Examine the role of the Opposition in shaping India's external engagement.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Foreign affairs is a Union subject (Entry 10, List I), and Article 73 gives it to the Union executive. That executive is still answerable to Parliament. The Leader of the Opposition (LoP) recently attacked India's absence from the US–China–Russia meeting at APEC, Shenzhen [1], which revives an old question. India's core interests should be insulated by consensus. The way it pursues them must remain open to partisan scrutiny.
Case for insulation
- Credibility abroad: a divided voice weakens bargaining power. After Operation Sindoor (2025), multi-party delegations went abroad to convey India's "united resolve against terrorism" [2].
- Continuity: strategic autonomy, the Act East line and the nuclear doctrine have survived changes of government.
- Against personalisation: calling the PM "compromised" over a forum India does not belong to, India is not an APEC member [1], is rhetoric, not oversight.
Case against total insulation
- Accountability: treaties, trade deals and conflict choices affect citizens. The 2008 Indo-US nuclear deal led to the Left withdrawing support and a confidence vote, which made the trade-offs public.
- Course correction: asking why India is a "side player" while Pakistan mediates between the US and Iran [1] forces the government to explain its strategy.
Role of the Opposition
- Committee oversight: the Standing Committee on External Affairs is chaired by Congress MP Shashi Tharoor. It examines areas such as tech diplomacy and Neighbourhood First [3].
- Representing the nation: Opposition MPs led Operation Sindoor delegations, and the PM later met them to acknowledge their work [4].
- Precedent: in 1994, PM Narasimha Rao sent the LoP, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, to lead India's delegation at the UN Human Rights Commission in Geneva.
- Limits: the LoP is a statutory post (1977 Act) with no formal foreign-policy role. Treaties need no parliamentary ratification. Criticism made abroad can turn into point-scoring.
Partisan politics should stay out of national interests, but policy choices should stay open to debate. Three steps would help: structured briefings for Opposition leaders, debate in Parliament on major agreements, and stronger committees. Together these would make criticism based on evidence, not slogans. That would honour collective responsibility to the Lok Sabha (Article 75(3)) while India speaks to the world with one voice.
Sources
- 1Rahul targets PM over India's place on the global stage, The Hindu, 21 Nov 2026 (news report)LoP's Shenzhen/APEC criticism, "compromised PM" remark, India not an APEC member, "side player" and Pakistan mediation remarks
- 2PIB: Meeting of the All Party Delegation led by Shri Sanjay Kumar Jha with Singapore's Senior Minister of State (27 May 2025)multi-party delegations conveying India's united resolve against terrorism
- 3PRS Legislative Research: Standing Committee on External Affairscommittee chaired by Shashi Tharoor; reports on tech diplomacy and Neighbourhood First
- 4PIB: Prime Minister meets members of various delegations who represented India in various countriesPM's meeting with members of the Operation Sindoor delegations