·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityIR

"Strategic autonomy risks becoming strategic absence when great powers negotiate directly." Discuss with reference to recent developments in West Asia and the Indo-Pacific.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How autonomy can slide into absence
  2. Why absence is not the whole story
  3. Way forward

Strategic autonomy, India's freedom to choose partners and positions without joining blocs, has rested on being "friends with all". But when great powers bargain directly, an uncommitted India can end up consulted by none. The November 2026 US–China–Russia meeting at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, held without India, revived this debate [1].

How autonomy can slide into absence

  • West Asia: In the US–Israel war on Iran, Pakistan is acting as a go-between for Washington and Tehran. The Leader of the Opposition called India a "side player" [1]. Membership rules do not decide who mediates; trust does.
  • Indo-Pacific architecture: India applied to APEC in 1993, and a freeze on new members from 1997 kept it out [3]. The freeze lapsed years ago, yet India has not pressed its case, partly from fear of pressure to cut tariffs.
  • Unused groundwork: An RIS study, India and APEC: An Appraisal (2015), weighed the costs and gains of joining [4]. India has not acted on it.
  • Guest, not member: India attended the 2023 APEC Leaders' Meeting only as a guest economy [2]. A guest is present one year and absent the next.

Why absence is not the whole story

  • Structural, not personal: India is not an APEC member, so no Indian PM had a seat at Shenzhen as of right [1].
  • Multi-alignment: India sits in the Quad and IPEF with the US, and in BRICS and SCO with Russia and China. It joined IPEF's ministerial meetings in 2023 [2].
  • Bipartisan tradition: Personal charges such as "compromised PM" weaken the national consensus on foreign policy [1].

Way forward

  • Update the 2015 RIS appraisal and plan a phased APEC entry [4].
  • Build credibility as a mediator through steady ties with the Gulf states, Iran and Israel.
  • Use Parliament to ask fact-based questions about re-applying to APEC.

Strategic autonomy becomes absence only when it turns passive. India's gap at Shenzhen is largely structural, but its silence on West Asian mediation is a policy choice. Active multi-alignment, seeking seats where rules are written and offering itself as a trusted go-between, would fulfil the Act East vision and India's ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam.

Sources

  1. 1*Rahul targets PM over India's place on the global stage*, The Hindu, 21 Nov 2026 (news report)Shenzhen US–China–Russia meeting; India not in APEC; "side player" remark; Pakistan's mediation; "compromised PM" charge
  2. 2PIB: Union Commerce and Industry Minister Shri Piyush Goyal to visit San Francisco from 13-16 November 2023 to attend Leaders and Ministerial Engagements of IPEF and APECIndia as APEC guest economy (2023); IPEF ministerial participation
  3. 3MEA Distinguished Lectures (lecture on India's APEC application)India's 1993 application; 1997 membership freeze
  4. 4RIS, *India and APEC: An Appraisal* (V. S. Seshadri, 2015)government-linked study of the case for joining APEC
Practice
6 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity