·The Hindu

Taxes, policy uncertainty and lost investor confidence

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Is Tax Really the Main Reason? The Strongest Objection
  9. Why the 2012 Retro Tax Still Costs India Today
  10. How the 2026 Relief Creates New Uncertainty
  11. What Would Make India's Tax Rules Predictable
  12. Anchors for Answers
  13. Mains Relevance
  14. Related Topics to Study Next
  15. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  16. Common Errors / Trap Areas
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

1. At a Glance

  • Core idea: Tax rates matter to investors, but what they weigh most is whether policy is predictable, consistent and competitive. When several policy decisions in a row are inconsistent or costly, the damage to investor confidence is cumulative, and "optimism alone" will not restore it [1].
  • Why markets are weak: Indian equities have underperformed because several factors add up: taxation, regulatory uncertainty, liquidity constraints, cost of capital, corporate earnings pressure and the shifting priorities of global investors [1].
  • The State's own position: In 2021 the government accepted that retrospective taxation undermines tax certainty and makes India less attractive to investors. It said so when it repealed the 2012 indirect-transfer retro-tax [2].
  • UPSC relevance: The topic links GS-III (resource mobilisation, investment models, capital flows, FPI/FDI) with GS-II (policy design, the legislative process, ordinances) and with Prelims-level facts on tax law.

2. Why in the News

  • Market rally in November 2026: About ₹15,000 crore flowed into Indian equity markets after the U.S. midterm election results. The op-ed argues this should not hide the structural question of whether India has become hard for global capital to navigate [1].
  • Two-year underperformance (as cited in the op-ed): Over two years, KOSPI (South Korea) +160%, KSE-100 (Pakistan) +107%, TAIEX (Taiwan) +105%, Nikkei-225 (Japan) +70%, DAX (Germany) +30%, FTSE100 (UK) +26%, while India's Nifty 50 fell 14% [1].
  • Tax relief by ordinance in June 2026: With FPIs pulling money out and the rupee under pressure, the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 removed tax on FPI gains from Government Securities (G-Secs). It was published in the Gazette of India (Extraordinary) on 5 June 2026 and inserts Serial Nos. 13D and 13E into Schedule IV of the Income-tax Act, 2025 [3][4].
  • Equity gains still taxed: The exemption does not cover equity. LTCG on FPI equity stays at 12.5% [3][4].

3. Background & Evolution

  • 2012, the starting point: The Finance Act, 2012 amended Section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 with retrospective effect, so that indirect transfers of Indian assets became taxable. This undid a Supreme Court judgment in the Vodafone case [2] [BG for the Vodafone link].
  • 2012–2021, a long dispute: Tax demands based on this amendment led to international arbitration (Vodafone, Cairn), which hurt India's reputation on tax certainty [5].
  • August 2021, repeal: The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 was introduced on 5 August 2021 and received Presidential assent on 13 August 2021 [2].
  • It removed the retrospective effect for indirect transfers that took place before 28 May 2012.
  • It nullified the related tax demands and provided for refunds of tax already collected [2].
  • The government stated the aim as restoring tax certainty and reassuring investors that India does not favour retrospective taxation [2].

  • July 2024, higher capital gains tax: Union Budget 2024-25 raised LTCG to 12.5% (from 10%) and equity STCG to 20% (from 15%). It also raised STT on F&O and abolished "angel tax" [5].

  • 2025–26, new tax law: The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act. Section 210 sets out a specific regime for taxing FIIs on income from securities and on capital gains [3][4].
  • June 2026: The G-Sec capital-gains exemption for FPIs was brought in by ordinance (see Section 2) [3][4].

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Retrospective taxation A law that taxes past transactions, reaching back before the law was made; the core example of policy uncertainty [2]
Indirect transfer Sale of shares in a foreign company whose value comes substantially from assets in India; brought under Sec. 9 in 2012 [2]
Repeal law Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021; cut-off date 28 May 2012; demands nullified, refunds allowed [2]
Current tax law Income-tax Act, 2025, replacing the IT Act, 1961 [3][4]
FII taxation provision Section 210, IT Act 2025 [3][4]
FII rate structure (as reported) Income from securities 20%; STCG 30%; LTCG 12.5% [3][4]*
G-Sec exemption route Ordinance (Art. 123) → Schedule IV, entries 13D, 13E; Gazette dated 5 June 2026 [3][4]
Administering department Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance; CBDT for direct taxes [5]
Constitutional basis Art. 265: no tax except by authority of law. Art. 123: President's ordinance power [5]
Benchmark index Nifty 50 (NSE): −14% over two years, against large gains in peer Asian markets [1]

*The rate figures come from press coverage of the PIB FAQ. Check them against the FAQ text.

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Economic

  • Equity weakness has many causes at once: tax, regulation, liquidity, cost of capital, earnings and global allocation choices. Changing the tax rate alone will not fix it [1].
  • A short burst of inflows, such as the ₹15,000 crore after the U.S. midterms, can hide a long-term retreat of capital [1].
  • FPI outflows put pressure on the rupee and on bond yields. Exempting G-Sec gains was meant to support debt inflows and the currency [3][4].
  • When investors see policy risk, they demand a higher risk premium. This raises the cost of capital and makes private investment more expensive [1].

Legal / Constitutional

  • Art. 265 gives Parliament the power to legislate taxes retrospectively. The 2021 repeal shows that having legal power is not the same as having credibility with investors [2] [5].
  • Using an ordinance for tax relief (2026) speeds up the response. Critics see it as another example of policy made in reaction to events, without a consultative process [3][4].
  • Investment-treaty arbitration exposed the gap between India's domestic tax powers and its obligations under Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) [5].

Governance / Ethical

  • Predictability is a public good. Frequent changes to rates, holding periods, STT and exemptions erode trust even when each change can be defended on its own merits [1].
  • Consultation and sunset clauses: good regulatory practice calls for pre-legislative consultation, grandfathering and stable multi-year roadmaps [5].
  • The government faces a trade-off between raising revenue (capital gains as an equity-based tax) and staying competitive for mobile capital [3][4].

Geopolitical / Strategic

  • The interests of international investors shift with events such as U.S. elections and geopolitical shocks. India competes for the same capital as KOSPI, TAIEX and Nikkei markets [1].
  • If peer markets rally while India's falls, it weakens the "China+1" investment-destination argument for portfolio capital [1] [5].

Administrative

  • Implementation risk: a new Income-tax Act (2025) followed soon by amending ordinances creates a transition period in which rules change quickly [3][4].
  • Tax demands and litigation that drag on (the 2012–2021 retro-tax period) tie up capital and management time [2].

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 5 June 2026: The Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 was gazetted. It exempts FPI capital gains on G-Secs through Schedule IV entries 13D/13E of the IT Act, 2025 [3][4].
  • June 2026: PIB issued FAQ documents explaining the Section 210 FII taxation framework and the scope of the exemption. Equity LTCG for FPIs was left unchanged at 12.5% [3][4].
  • H1 2026: Press reports describe heavy net FPI outflows in 2026, already above the total for 2025 by mid-year. The figures differ by source (equity-only vs. all flows), so treat them as indicative only [3][S4 context].
  • November 2026: About ₹15,000 crore of equity inflows came in after the U.S. midterm elections, while the Nifty 50 showed a −14% two-year return [1].
  • 17 November 2026: An op-ed in The Hindu (Page 6, Delhi edition) by MP Shashi Tharoor argued that predictability, not the level of tax rates, drives investor confidence [1].

7. Prelims Hooks

  • The Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 removed retrospective taxation of indirect transfers [2].
  • The cut-off date in the 2021 Act is 28 May 2012. No fresh demand can be raised for indirect transfers before this date [2].
  • The 2021 Act nullified past demands and provided for refunds of retro-tax collected [2].
  • The Bill was introduced on 5 August 2021 and received assent on 13 August 2021 [2].
  • The 2012 retro-amendment was made to Section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which covers income deemed to accrue or arise in India [2].
  • Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, FII taxation is governed by Section 210 [3][4].
  • The 2026 FPI G-Sec exemption was made through an ordinance, not a Finance Act. It inserted entries 13D and 13E in Schedule IV [3][4].
  • The Gazette date of the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 is 5 June 2026 [3][4].
  • The 2026 exemption covers government securities only. FPI equity LTCG remains at 12.5% [3][4].
  • Under the FII regime, STCG is reportedly taxed at 30% and income from securities at 20% [3][4].
  • LTCG on listed equity was raised from 10% to 12.5% in Union Budget 2024-25 (July 2024) [5].
  • Art. 265: no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law [5].
  • The indices cited in the op-ed belong to these countries: KOSPI (South Korea), TAIEX (Taiwan), KSE-100 (Pakistan), DAX (Germany), FTSE100 (UK), Nikkei-225 (Japan) [1].

8. Is Tax Really the Main Reason? The Strongest Objection

  • The op-ed itself says tax is only one of six causes
  • It lists tax, regulation, liquidity (how easily shares can be bought and sold), cost of capital, company earnings and the changing choices of global investors, all acting together [1].
  • The index comparison cannot tell us how much of the Nifty's 14% fall is due to tax and how much to the other five [1].
  • So the comparison shows that India fell behind. It does not prove that tax uncertainty is the reason.

  • Policy certainty cannot explain every rally on the list

  • Pakistan's KSE-100 rose 107% over the same two years [1].
  • Pakistan is not known for predictable economic policy. Its rally suggests that other forces, such as a market starting from very low prices, can matter more than policy certainty.

  • The research is weaker than the slogan

  • In 2017 the IMF and OECD reported to the G20 that the evidence linking tax uncertainty to investment is sparse [7].
  • The evidence that does exist points one way: uncertainty hurts investment and trade [7].
  • Businesses surveyed said tax certainty matters when they decide where to invest [7].

  • The honest answer

  • The objection is right that tax is not the whole story. The op-ed is an argument by an MP, not a study [1].
  • But tax is the one cause the government controls directly. It cannot order company earnings to rise or global investors to return.
  • So tax certainty is the right place for policy to start, even if it is not the biggest cause.

9. Why the 2012 Retro Tax Still Costs India Today

  • India was warned seven years before it repealed the tax
  • The Tax Administration Reform Commission (TARC), chaired by Dr Parthasarathi Shome, gave its First Report on 30 May 2014 [6].
  • It said retrospective taxation needed immediate attention. It also said that handling tax disputes well was key to winning back taxpayers' confidence [6].
  • The repeal came only in August 2021 [2]. For seven more years, every foreign investor looking at India had to count the retro-tax as a risk.

  • The repeal cost money but did not remove the risk

  • The 2021 Act cancelled the demands and refunded tax already collected [2]. India gave up that revenue.
  • But the repeal covered only one provision. Parliament can still tax past transactions if it chooses [2].
  • So a careful investor still adds a risk premium (the extra return demanded to cover the chance of a loss) before putting money into India.
  • India paid the cost of imposing the tax and the cost of withdrawing it, and still did not fully win back trust.

10. How the 2026 Relief Creates New Uncertainty

  • An ordinance is temporary by design
  • An ordinance under Article 123 lapses six weeks after Parliament meets again, unless Parliament passes it as a law [5].
  • So a foreign bond investor planning for five years has to ask whether Parliament will confirm the exemption, and whether the next Budget will change it.

  • Giving relief when money leaves teaches investors to wait for more relief

  • The exemption came while FPIs were pulling money out and the rupee was weak [3][4].
  • If tax rules change whenever money flows out, investors learn that the rules follow market pressure, not a plan. That is the opposite of predictability.

  • Bonds get relief, shares do not

  • FPI gains on G-Secs are now exempt, but FPI equity LTCG stays at 12.5% [3][4].
  • This can pull foreign money towards government bonds and away from company shares, the very market where the Nifty has fallen [1].
  • It helps the government borrow more cheaply. It does little for the cost of capital of private companies (the return investors demand before they will fund a company), which is the problem the op-ed raises [1].

11. What Would Make India's Tax Rules Predictable

  • Parliament should pass the ordinance as a Bill, after review by a committee
  • Sending it to the Standing Committee on Finance would let investors and experts give their views in public.
  • A law made this way carries more weight with investors than an executive order made in a hurry [3][4].

  • The Finance Ministry should publish a capital gains plan covering several years

  • Rates changed in 2024 and the tax law was replaced in 2025 [3][4]. Investors now fear the next change more than today's rate.
  • A published schedule of future rates, with grandfathering (existing investments keep the old rules), removes that fear.

  • CBDT should follow TARC's advice on settling disputes

  • TARC said that handling disputes well is central to winning back confidence [6].
  • The 2012–2021 retro-tax demands show how a long dispute can hang over investors for nearly a decade [2].

  • India should test its rules against the G20 work on tax certainty

  • G20 leaders at the 2016 Hangzhou summit asked the IMF and OECD to prepare the 2017 report on tax certainty [7].
  • India is a G20 member. It can check its own tax-making process against that report instead of starting from scratch.

12. Anchors for Answers

  • Data: Nifty 50 fell 14% over two years, while KOSPI rose 160% and TAIEX 105% over the same period [1]
  • Data: About ₹15,000 crore of equity inflows came after the U.S. midterms, a short-term burst set against a long-term slide [1]
  • Report/Committee: Tax Administration Reform Commission (Parthasarathi Shome), First Report, 2014. It flagged retrospective taxation for immediate attention [6]
  • Report/Committee: IMF–OECD Report on Tax Certainty to G20 Finance Ministers, 2017. It found that uncertainty harms investment and trade [7]
  • Law/Case: Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 (retro-tax repeal) [2]; Art. 265 (tax only by authority of law); Art. 123 (ordinances); Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 [3][4]

13. Mains Relevance

14. Related Topics to Study Next

  • FPI vs FDI regulation (SEBI FPI Regulations, FEMA): to understand which capital is "mobile" and how each type is taxed.
  • Income-tax Act, 2025: the structural change behind the new section numbers (e.g., Sec. 210).
  • GAAR and the Principal Purpose Test (MLI): another source of uncertainty in anti-avoidance rules.
  • Bilateral Investment Treaties and the Model BIT 2016: the arbitration fallout from Vodafone and Cairn.
  • Rupee depreciation and RBI forex intervention: how capital outflows feed into currency stability.
  • Securities Transaction Tax and F&O regulation: the cost of transacting and the liquidity constraints the op-ed points to.
  • Ease of Doing Business and regulatory impact assessment: institutional tools for predictable policymaking.
  • Ordinance-making power (Art. 123), D.C. Wadhwa and Krishna Kumar Singh cases: the limits on legislating by the executive.

15. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Retrospective taxation (Economy): The central example of policy uncertainty; the 2012 amendment and its 2021 repeal drive the article's argument.
  • Foreign portfolio investment (Economy): FPIs are the mobile capital whose outflows, tax relief and confidence the article is about.
  • Capital gains tax (Economy): LTCG and STCG rate changes, including the 12.5% equity rate, are a key investor concern.
  • Ordinance-making power of the President (Polity): The June 2026 FPI tax relief came by ordinance under Art. 123, raising predictability questions.
  • Government securities (Economy): The 2026 ordinance exempted FPI capital gains on G-Secs, so you need to know what they are.
  • Cost of capital (Economy): Policy risk raises the return investors demand, making private investment more expensive.
  • Model Bilateral Investment Treaty, 2016 (Economy): India's treaty template adopted after the Vodafone and Cairn arbitration losses over retro-tax.
  • Arbitration (Polity): Vodafone and Cairn won international arbitration against India's retro-tax demands, hurting its reputation.
  • Securities Transaction Tax (Economy): Higher STT on F&O is cited as a transaction cost behind weak liquidity and market sentiment.
  • Nifty 50 (Economy): Its 14% two-year fall, against big gains in peer markets, is the article's headline comparison.
  • Pre-legislative consultation (Polity): Consulting on draft laws before passing them is a remedy for sudden, unpredictable tax changes.
  • Forex intervention (Economy): FPI outflows pressure the rupee, and RBI intervention is how currency stability is defended.
  • Liquidity (Economy): Liquidity constraints are one of the listed causes of weak Indian equity performance.
  • Angel tax (Economy): Its abolition in the 2024 Budget is one of the tax changes the note cites.
  • Foreign Direct Investment (Economy): Contrast FDI with FPI to see why portfolio capital is more mobile and sensitive to policy.

16. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Repeal ≠ abolition of the power: The 2021 Act removed one retrospective provision. It did not take away Parliament's constitutional power to legislate retrospectively.
  • Cut-off date confusion: The date is 28 May 2012, the date the Finance Act 2012 received assent. Do not confuse it with the 2007 Vodafone–Hutchison deal or the 2021 repeal date.
  • Section numbering: Sec. 9 (deemed accrual) belongs to the IT Act, 1961. Sec. 210 (FII regime) belongs to the IT Act, 2025. Do not mix the two Acts.
  • Scope of the 2026 relief: It applies only to G-Secs (debt). Equity LTCG for FPIs is unchanged at 12.5%.
  • FPI outflow figures: Sources differ on whether they count equity only or all flows. Check the category before quoting a number.

Sources

  1. 1Shashi Tharoor, "Taxes, policy uncertainty and lost investor confidence", The Hindu, 17 Nov 2026, p. 6 (Delhi)thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2PRS Legislative Research, Bill Summary: Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2021prsindia.org · tier 1
  3. 3PIB document (FAQ on FII/FPI taxation and the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026), June 2026static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  4. 4PIB document (FAQ / explanatory note, June 2026)static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  5. 5Standard background knowledge, not retrieved in this session from a whitelisted source. Check before relying on it for an exam.
  6. 6PRS Legislative Research, Report Summary: First Report of the Tax Administration Reforms Commissionprsindia.org · tier 1
  7. 7IMF–OECD, Tax Certainty: Report for the G20 Finance Ministers (March 2017)imf.org · tier 2
At the end · practice MCQs
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

Mains Q&A on this note

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 17 November

All 17 November articles →