·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEconomy

Critically evaluate using ordinances to make tax changes for foreign portfolio investors. Does it help or hurt policy predictability?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Merits of the ordinance route
  2. Demerits
  3. Net effect on predictability

Article 123 lets the President issue ordinances when Parliament is not in session. Article 265 says no tax may be levied or exempted except by authority of law. In June 2026, as FPIs pulled money out and the rupee weakened, the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 exempted FPI interest and capital gains on Government Securities [1][2]. The route was fast, but it costs predictability.

Merits of the ordinance route

  • Speed in a crisis: relief came without waiting for a session of Parliament. It signalled to bond investors that the government would act while outflows were hurting the rupee [1].
  • Clear, targeted scope: the ordinance inserted entries 13D/13E in Schedule IV of the Income-tax Act, 2025, covering only G-Secs, with effect from 1 April 2026 [1][2].
  • Legally valid: an ordinance has the force of law, so it meets Art. 265. It also helps the government borrow more cheaply.

Demerits

  • Temporary by design: an ordinance lapses six weeks after Parliament reassembles unless an Act replaces it. A bond investor planning five years ahead must price in that risk.
  • No deliberation: there is no Standing Committee scrutiny or pre-legislative consultation, so Parliament does not own the change.
  • Reactive signal: giving relief under market pressure teaches investors that rules follow outflows, not a plan.
  • Distortion: FPI equity LTCG stays at 12.5% [1][2]. Money is pulled towards sovereign debt, and private firms' cost of capital is left untouched.
  • Cumulative churn: rates changed in 2024, a new Act came in 2025, and an amending ordinance followed in 2026. This recalls the retro-tax episode, which India ended only through the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 to restore tax certainty [3]. The Shome-led TARC (2014) had already warned against retrospective amendments [4].

Net effect on predictability

  • Short run, it helps: investors know at once how their G-Sec income will be taxed.
  • Long run, it hurts: the IMF–OECD report to the G20 (2017) found that tax uncertainty harms investment and trade [5]. Predictability comes from a stable process, not from how fast a change is made.

Ordinances are a useful emergency tool but a poor way to set tax policy for mobile capital. The way forward is to:

  • pass the ordinance as a Bill after review by the Standing Committee on Finance;
  • publish a multi-year capital-gains roadmap that protects existing investments under the old rules;
  • adopt TARC's dispute-resolution advice [4] and the G20 tax-certainty toolkit [5].

Speed calms markets for a while, but only consultative lawmaking in the spirit of Article 265 earns lasting trust.

Sources

  1. 1PIB – FAQ on FII taxation and the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026 (June 2026)G-Sec exemption amid outflows; Schedule IV entries 13D/13E; effective date; equity LTCG unchanged
  2. 2PIB – Explanatory note/FAQ, June 2026scope of the G-Sec-only exemption; FPI equity LTCG at 12.5%
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research – Bill Summary: Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2021retro-tax repeal to restore tax certainty
  4. 4PRS Legislative Research – Report Summary: First Report of the Tax Administration Reforms Commission (2014)TARC on avoiding retrospective amendments and on resolving disputes
  5. 5IMF–OECD, Tax Certainty: Report for the G20 Finance Ministers (March 2017)uncertainty harms investment and trade; tools for tax certainty
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity