·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolitySociety

"Data-driven inclusion requires institutions, not just schemes." Discuss with reference to the Equal Opportunity Commission and the National Data Bank proposed by the Sachar Committee.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why schemes alone fall short
  2. Equal Opportunity Commission: enforcing fairness
  3. National Data Bank and Assessment & Monitoring Authority: measuring progress
  4. Limits of the institutional argument

The Sachar Committee (2006) recorded Muslim shortfalls in literacy, salaried jobs and access to credit [1]. The government accepted 72 of its 76 recommendations [2]. Twenty years on, the institutions meant to enforce and measure inclusion still do not exist. That is the gap this statement points to.

Why schemes alone fall short

  • Schemes provide inputs. They cannot find discrimination or measure results. Official follow-up counts decisions taken, not gains in schooling or jobs [2].
  • The Kundu Committee (2014) concluded that "a start has been made, yet serious bottlenecks remain" [3]. Its recommendations were then only sent to ministries for their views [4]. With no institution in charge, accountability was spread thin.

Equal Opportunity Commission: enforcing fairness

  • Sachar wanted an EOC to hear complaints from all deprived groups [1]. That is a needs-based design, consistent with Articles 14–16.
  • An expert group reported in 2008. The diversity index, which scores how well education, housing and jobs reflect the population, was then merged into the EOC proposal [5].
  • In 2017 the draft EOC Bill was still being sent round ministries for consultation [6]. Because the two ideas had been merged, one stuck file held up both.

National Data Bank and Assessment & Monitoring Authority: measuring progress

  • Sachar's own figures show what is at stake: Muslim literacy was 59.1% against 64.8% nationally (2001), and Muslims held only about 4% of police posts [1].
  • The NDB and the Monitoring Authority were proposed to keep community-wise data and track outcomes [2]. Without them, nobody can show whether the PM's New 15-Point Programme has succeeded or failed.

Limits of the institutional argument

  • An institution without political will becomes a paper body. The National Commission for Minorities exists, yet deprivation remains.
  • Data collected by religion alone draws charges of "appeasement". It has to be broken down by caste, gender and region to reach the poorest groups within the community, such as the Pasmanda.

Schemes carry inclusion out, but institutions measure it and hold the State to account. Three steps would turn Sachar's evidence into results someone must answer for: a statutory EOC open to all deprived groups, a separate diversity index linked to funding, and a National Data Bank aligned with the coming Census. Together they would serve Article 38 and SDG 10's promise to leave no one behind.

Sources

  1. 1Summary of Sachar Committee Report — PRS Legislative ResearchEOC for all deprived groups; literacy, police-share data; development deficits
  2. 2Lok Sabha answers on Sachar Committee follow-up (2013–14), Parliament Digital Library72 of 76 recommendations accepted; decisions-based monitoring; National Data Bank and Assessment & Monitoring Authority
  3. 3Kundu Committee Submits Post Sachchar Evaluation Report — PIBpost-Sachar evaluation (2014); "serious bottlenecks remain"
  4. 4Action Taken on The Report of Amitabh Kundu Committee — PIBrecommendations sent to ministries for views
  5. 5Implementation of Recommendations of Sachar Committee — PIB2008 expert groups; diversity index merged into EOC proposal
  6. 6Draft Equal Opportunity Commission Bill Re-Circulated for Inter-Ministerial Consultations — PIBEOC Bill still pending in 2017
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity