Despite strong macro fundamentals, Indian equities have underperformed peer Asian markets. Analyse the role of policy uncertainty, and suggest measures to restore investor confidence.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
In recent years Indian benchmark indices have fallen behind peers such as South Korea's KOSPI and Taiwan's TAIEX, even though India's growth and macro stability remain sound. Policy uncertainty is not the only cause. It is the one cause the State controls directly, and it raises the risk premium investors demand.
Role of policy uncertainty
- Legacy of retrospective tax: The 2012 retrospective tax on indirect transfers was withdrawn only by the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021, which cancelled the demands and refunded the tax collected [1]. The TARC (Shome, 2014) had flagged retrospective taxation for immediate attention [2]. That seven-year delay, and Parliament's continuing power to tax past transactions, keep the risk priced in.
- Rate churn: Budget 2024-25 raised LTCG to 12.5% and STCG to 20% on certain financial assets [3]. The Income-tax Act, 2025 then replaced the 1961 law [4]. Investors now worry more about the next change than about today's rate.
- Reactive, ordinance-based relief: The June 2026 Ordinance exempted FII income from G-Secs while money was flowing out [4][5]. An Art. 123 ordinance lapses unless Parliament approves it. Relief given under market pressure tells investors that rules follow outflows, not a plan.
- Debt-equity asymmetry: The relief covers government bonds only [5]. It lowers the State's borrowing cost but does nothing for the cost of equity capital.
- Evidence: The IMF–OECD report to the G20 (2017) found that tax uncertainty hurts investment and trade [6].
- Calibration: Earnings pressure, liquidity, valuations and shifts in global allocation also weigh on markets. Uncertainty adds to these drags rather than being the sole cause.
Measures to restore confidence
- Legislate, don't decree: Pass the ordinance as a Bill after review by the Standing Committee on Finance.
- Multi-year capital-gains roadmap with grandfathering, so existing investments keep the old rules.
- Pre-legislative consultation and a declared policy against retrospective tax.
- Faster dispute resolution, as TARC advised [2].
- G20 benchmarking: Adopt the tax-certainty tools recommended by the IMF–OECD [6].
- Non-tax reforms: Deepen market liquidity and keep SEBI regulation stable.
Investors weigh how predictable taxes are as much as how high they are. A stable, consultative, rule-based tax regime would turn India's macro strength into market performance, and it would match the transparency and certainty expected under Art. 265's "authority of law".
Sources
- 1PRS Legislative Research – Bill Summary: Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2021withdrawal of the retrospective indirect-transfer tax, demands cancelled, refunds
- 2PRS Legislative Research – Report Summary: First Report of the Tax Administration Reforms Commission (2014)retrospective tax flagged for immediate attention; dispute resolution
- 3PIB – Capital Gains Taxation Simplified and Rationalised (Union Budget 2024-25)LTCG 12.5%, STCG 20% on certain financial assets
- 4PIB – FAQ on taxation of FIIs and the Income-tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2026shift from the IT Act 1961 to the 2025 regime; G-Sec exemption by ordinance
- 5All India Radio News – Centre grants tax exemption to FPIs on capital gains and interest income from G-Secs (5 June 2026)ordinance date; relief limited to government securities
- 6IMF–OECD, Tax Certainty: Report for the G20 Finance Ministers (March 2017)uncertainty harms investment and trade; G20 tax-certainty tools
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.