·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEconomy

"The 'commercial wisdom' of the Committee of Creditors is not beyond statutory scrutiny." Discuss in light of recent Supreme Court rulings on resolution plans under the IBC.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Commercial wisdom: where courts defer
  2. Statutory scrutiny: where that wisdom ends
  3. Concerns
  4. Way forward

Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), the Committee of Creditors (CoC) approves a resolution plan with at least 66% of its vote [2]. Courts treat its "commercial wisdom" as largely final. Recent Supreme Court rulings show that this wisdom still has to stay within the law.

Commercial wisdom: where courts defer

  • In Essar Steel (2019), the SC held that the tribunals cannot question the CoC's business decisions on merits. It also held that creditors must be treated "equitably", not "equally" [3].
  • Whether a plan's price is right, and whether the plan is feasible and viable, is for creditors to decide, not judges [2].

Statutory scrutiny: where that wisdom ends

  • The 2019 amendment to Section 30 requires a "fair and equitable" distribution. It also requires that a creditor who votes against the plan (a dissenter) gets at least what it would receive in liquidation under Section 53 [2].
  • Twinstar–Videocon (2026): the CoC approved a ₹2,962-crore plan for 13 Videocon firms with 95.09% of the vote. Dissenters were to be paid through deferred debentures, meaning payment years later. The SC upheld the NCLAT's order sending the plan back, because this broke the mandatory payment rule [1].
  • So even a 95% majority cannot vote away a statutory minimum. That minimum protects each creditor separately [1][2].
  • The Court also limited the tribunals' role: they may remit a plan to the CoC but not rewrite it [1].

Concerns

  • Delay: the NCLAT sent the plan back in 2022, and the SC decided only in 2026 [1]. In 2021, 13,170 IBC cases were pending before the NCLT, about 71% of them for over 180 days [4].
  • Bidder risk: if approved plans can be reopened, bidders may offer less.
  • Deep haircuts: Videocon's 95.85% haircut matches Parliament's finding of haircuts of up to 95% [1][4].

Way forward

  • A code of conduct for CoCs and dedicated NCLT benches, as the Standing Committee on Finance (2021) recommended [4].
  • An upfront deposit from unsuccessful applicants who appeal, as the Committee's 28th Report (2025) suggested [5].
  • An IBBI rule stating that dissenters' minimum must be paid in cash or its present-value equivalent.

Taken together, Essar Steel and Videocon set the line: courts defer to creditors on business choices but enforce the Code's minimum guarantees. Faster tribunals and clearer rules would let this check work without long delays. That keeps the IBC's goal of maximising value fair to every creditor.

Sources

  1. 1SC upholds NCLAT order to revisit ₹2,962-cr. Videocon plan — The Hindu, 17 Nov 2026Videocon plan value, 95.09% vote, deferred debentures, remit-not-rewrite rule, 95.85% haircut, 2022–2026 timeline (exact article page could not be verified, so the link is the site root)
  2. 2The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 26 of 2019) — PRS India%20Act,%202019.pdf) — 66% approval threshold, "fair and equitable" distribution, dissenters' liquidation-value floor under Section 53
  3. 3Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta (SC, 15 Nov 2019) — IBBI orders repositoryCoC commercial wisdom not open to review on merits; equitable, not equal, treatment
  4. 4Implementation of IBC – Pitfalls and Solutions, Standing Committee on Finance (2021) — PRS report summaryhaircuts of up to 95%, 13,170 pending cases (71% over 180 days), CoC code of conduct, dedicated NCLT benches
  5. 5Review of Working of IBC and Emerging Issues, Standing Committee on Finance, 28th Report (2025) — PRS summaryupfront deposit from unsuccessful resolution applicants who appeal
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity