Steep haircuts and long delays have weakened the IBC's promise of time-bound value maximisation. Examine, and suggest reforms.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 promised to rescue distressed firms quickly and at full value. Since the 2019 amendment, resolution must finish within 330 days, including litigation [2]. In practice, deep haircuts and long delays have weakened that promise, though the Code has still beaten the old system.
How the promise has weakened
- Steep haircuts: Twinstar's ₹2,962-crore plan for 13 Videocon firms was set against claims of about ₹64,839 crore, a 95.85% haircut [1]. A Parliamentary panel noted haircuts of up to 95% [3], and its 2025 review flagged low recovery against admitted claims [4].
- Delays as the norm: 13,170 cases were pending before the NCLT, and 71% had passed 180 days [3].
- Multi-tier litigation: In Videocon, the NCLT approved the plan in 2021 and the NCLAT remitted it in 2022. The Supreme Court ruled only in 2026, holding that tribunals may remit but not rewrite plans [1].
- Self-reinforcing cycle: Delay wears down a firm's assets, contracts and staff. Bids then come in close to liquidation value, which deepens the haircut.
- Institutional gaps: Over 50% of NCLT sanctioned posts were vacant [3], and frivolous litigation added to delays [4].
The other side
- Average resolution time fell from 4.3 to 1.6 years (2017–20) [3], and 1,194 companies have been resolved [4].
- Many haircuts reflect value lost before admission, not failure under the IBC.
Reforms
- Capacity: dedicated, fast-track IBC benches and quick filling of vacancies [3][4].
- Haircut benchmark comparable to global standards [3]. This should be a guide, not a rigid cap that drives bidders away.
- CoC code of conduct, so that "commercial wisdom" stays accountable [3].
- Curb delaying appeals: an upfront deposit from unsuccessful resolution applicants who appeal [4].
- Codify the Videocon principle: an IBBI rule that dissenters' liquidation-value floor [2] be paid in cash or its present-value equivalent. This would prevent remands like the one over deferred debentures [1].
- Earlier entry: extend pre-packaged insolvency beyond MSMEs, and frame a group-insolvency law.
Haircuts and delays feed each other, but the IBC's design is still sound. The weak point is how fast it is put into practice. With more tribunal capacity, clear rules on plans and fewer stalling appeals, the IBC can deliver the time-bound value maximisation Parliament intended and support a healthier credit culture.
Sources
- 1SC upholds NCLAT order to revisit ₹2,962-cr. Videocon plan — The Hindu, 17 Nov 2026 (news)Videocon plan value, claims, 95.85% haircut, NCLT/NCLAT/SC timeline, remit-not-rewrite holding, deferred-debenture defect
- 2The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Bill, 2019 — PRS Bill Track330-day limit including litigation; dissenting creditors' liquidation-value floor
- 3Implementation of IBC – Pitfalls and Solutions, Standing Committee on Finance (2021) — PRS Report Summaryhaircuts up to 95%, 13,170 pending cases (71% over 180 days), NCLT vacancies, 4.3→1.6 years, haircut benchmark, dedicated benches, CoC code of conduct
- 4Review of Working of IBC and Emerging Issues, Standing Committee on Finance 28th Report (2025) — PRS Report Summarylow recovery, frivolous litigation, fast-track benches, 1,194 companies resolved, upfront deposit for appeals
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.