Critically evaluate how well the IBC protects dissenting and minority creditors.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016, a resolution plan approved by at least 66% of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) by voting share binds every creditor [2]. Dissenting and minority creditors therefore rely on minimums set in the law, not on their votes. On paper the IBC protects them well. In practice, deep haircuts and long delays weaken that protection.
Safeguards that work
- Liquidation-value floor: since the 2019 amendment, a dissenting financial creditor must get at least what it would receive in liquidation under Section 53 [3].
- Fair distribution test: before approving a plan, the CoC must weigh its feasibility, its viability and the manner of distribution among creditors [2].
- The majority cannot override the statute: in the Videocon case, 95.09% of the CoC voted for Twinstar's ₹2,962-crore plan. The plan still failed because it paid dissenters through deferred debentures. In November 2026 the Supreme Court upheld the NCLAT's order sending the plan back to the CoC [1].
- Commercial wisdom kept intact: tribunals may remit a plan, not rewrite it [1]. Courts check whether the plan is legal, not whether the price is right.
Gaps that remain
- The floor is low: liquidation value is already a distress price. Videocon's haircut was 95.85% on admitted claims of about ₹64,839 crore [1]. The Standing Committee on Finance (2021) recorded haircuts of up to 95% [4].
- Form of payment is unsettled: whether deferred paper meets the floor is decided case by case, and only after years of litigation [1].
- Delay eats value: 13,170 IBC cases were pending before the NCLT, about 71% of them for over 180 days [4]. The Videocon remand of 2022 was settled only in 2026 [1].
- Majority dominance: beyond the floor, the CoC's commercial wisdom is treated as final. Dissenters have no say in how the plan is designed [4].
Way forward
- An IBBI regulation requiring the floor to be paid in cash or its present value (its worth in today's money).
- A benchmark for haircuts and a code of conduct for CoCs [4].
- Dedicated NCLT benches [4], and an upfront deposit from losing bidders who appeal, so appeals are not used just to stall [5].
Overall, the IBC gives dissenting creditors a legal floor that even a near-unanimous majority cannot breach. That floor is low, though, and slow to enforce. Settling the form of payment, adding tribunal capacity and benchmarking haircuts would turn protection on paper into real recovery. That would serve the Code's promise of time-bound, fair resolution, as Parliament's Finance Committee has urged.
Sources
- 1SC upholds NCLAT order to revisit ₹2,962-cr. Videocon plan — The Hindu, 17 Nov 2026Videocon facts: 95.09% CoC vote, deferred debentures, remit-not-rewrite, 95.85% haircut, ₹64,839-crore claims, timeline
- 2The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 26 of 2019) — PRS India%20Act,%202019.pdf) — 66% approval threshold; feasibility, viability and manner of distribution
- 3The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Bill, 2019 — PRS Bill Trackliquidation-value floor for dissenting financial creditors under Section 53
- 4Implementation of IBC – Pitfalls and Solutions, Standing Committee on Finance (2021) — PRS report summaryhaircuts up to 95%, 13,170 pending cases (71% over 180 days), haircut benchmark, CoC code of conduct, dedicated NCLT benches
- 5Review of Working of IBC and Emerging Issues, Standing Committee on Finance, 28th Report — PRS report summaryupfront deposit for unsuccessful resolution applicants who appeal