"The absence of a journalistic exemption in the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 threatens to turn a privacy law into a censorship tool." Critically examine.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Press freedom is implied in Article 19(1)(a), and privacy is a Fundamental Right under Article 21 (K.S. Puttaswamy). The DPDP Act, 2023 has no journalistic exemption. The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), which represents 21 publishers, has challenged it in the Supreme Court [1]. The fear of censorship is largely valid, but a properly drawn exemption can address it.
How the Act can become a censorship tool
- Consent works as a veto: the Act rests on the consent of the person the data is about [5]. In investigative stories, that person is usually the one being exposed. The DNPA calls this "a complete regime of pre-censorship" [1].
- Prior restraint: Article 19(2) allows the State to act after publication, through defamation or contempt law. A consent rule shifts control to before publication.
- Rights used against reporters: a powerful subject could use access and erasure rights to find out a reporter's sources or force removal of published reports [1].
- Weaker RTI: the Act amends RTI Section 8(1)(j) to exempt personal information outright [5]. This makes it harder to scrutinise public officials.
- A deliberate retreat: the 2018 draft Bill, which came with the Srikrishna Committee report, exempted journalistic purposes [4][2]. The 2019 Bill kept that exemption [3]. Since the State itself once drafted a gentler option, removing it entirely is hard to defend as the "least restrictive" choice under the proportionality test.
The case against a blanket exemption
- Privacy is an equal right: Puttaswamy gave privacy equal standing with free speech, not a lower one [1]. Victims, minors and marginalised people need protection from media exposure.
- Risk of misuse: anyone can call themselves a journalist. A wide exemption could shield doxxing, trial by media and gossip.
- Doubts existed even then: PRS questioned whether the 2018 journalism exemption met Puttaswamy's necessity and proportionality requirements [2].
Way forward
- Bring back a narrow exemption tied to the purpose of the work, as in the 2018 and 2019 drafts [2][3]. The test should be the purpose (public-interest reporting), not the person's job title.
- Make protection conditional on following ethical codes, such as Press Council of India norms.
- Rely on remedies after publication, such as defamation suits and privacy damages.
- Restore the public-interest test in RTI Section 8(1)(j).
- If Parliament does not act, the Supreme Court can read down the consent requirement so it does not apply to genuine newsgathering.
Taken together, the concern is valid. Without an exemption, a privacy law can be used to suppress reporting, but an unlimited exemption would wear down dignity. A narrow, purpose-based exemption that meets the proportionality test would protect both Article 19(1)(a) and Article 21. That balance is what the democratic accountability and constitutional morality behind Puttaswamy require.
Sources
- 1The Hindu, "Privacy vs press freedom: where should the line be drawn?" (16 Nov 2026)DNPA petition of 21 publishers; no journalistic exemption; "pre-censorship" argument; exposure of sources and removal of reports; Puttaswamy's equal standing for privacy
- 2PRS, Draft Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018exemption for journalistic purposes; PRS's doubts on necessity and proportionality
- 3PRS, The Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019journalistic exemption kept
- 4PRS Report Summary: A Free and Fair Digital Economy (Srikrishna Committee, 2018)committee report and draft Bill submitted to MeitY
- 5PRS Legislative Brief, The Digital Personal Data Protection Bill, 2023consent-based processing; amendment to RTI Section 8(1)(j)