·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityEnvironment

Assess how the NGT balances the precautionary principle with due process under Section 20 of the NGT Act, 2010.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Where the NGT applies precaution well
  2. Where due process is strained
  3. Assessment
  4. Way forward

Section 20 of the NGT Act, 2010 says the Tribunal "shall" apply sustainable development, the precautionary principle and polluter pays in every order. Section 19 asks it to be guided by natural justice [1]. In August 2026 the Supreme Court set aside the NGT's verdict on the World Culture Festival (Yamuna floodplain) case [2]. That ruling shows the NGT's balance has leaned towards precaution, at the cost of proof.

Where the NGT applies precaution well

  • Acting before harm: it allowed a festival on 25 ha of active floodplain only after the organisers deposited ₹5 crore as environmental compensation [2].
  • Expert-led fact-finding: it relies on expert committees and site inspections, not only on what the parties argue.
  • Continuing supervision: it monitors the demarcation of the 1-in-100-year Yamuna floodplain by the DDA [3].

Where due process is strained

  • Liability fixed before assessment: the deposit was taken before any damage existed, so it was never linked to measured harm.
  • No baseline: there was no record of the site's condition before the event. Without one, damage from a 3-day event cannot be separated from years of encroachment and dumping. The SC found no direct evidence that the festival caused the damage [2].
  • Causation ignored: the SC held that polluter pays needs proof of actual damage and a causal link to the activity [2]. Precaution cannot replace that proof.
  • Regulator left out: the DDA allotted the land but its own share of the blame was never examined. It now leads the rehabilitation, paid for with public money [2].

Assessment

  • The appeal route (Section 22) to the SC worked as a corrective [1]. But a refund with no one paying for restoration fails the polluter-pays principle as badly as liability without proof.

Way forward

  • Make a pre-activity baseline survey (soil, vegetation, satellite images), paid for by the applicant, a condition of any permission to use ecologically sensitive land.
  • Treat amounts fixed before an event as a security deposit. Set final compensation by comparing a survey after the event with the baseline.
  • Publish the demarcated floodplain map [3] so every permission is checked against a fixed line.

In short, the NGT has used Section 20 boldly but has applied precaution too late and proof too lightly. Collecting baselines before permission would apply precaution when it is fair and keep polluter pays credible. That would serve the right to a healthy environment under Article 21 and SDG 6 and SDG 15.

Sources

  1. 1The National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 (Act No. 19 of 2010), India CodeSection 20 ("shall" apply the three principles); Section 19 (natural justice); Section 22 (appeal to the Supreme Court)
  2. 2Supreme Court of India, Vyakti Vikas Kendra India v. Manoj Misra (Dead) & Ors., 2026 INSC 910, judgment dated 22 Aug 202625 ha floodplain site; ₹5 crore environmental compensation refunded; no direct evidence of damage; causal-link requirement; DDA to continue rehabilitation
  3. 3DDA / GNCTD progress reports to the NGT in OA No. 537 of 2023 (Yamuna floodplain demarcation), National Green TribunalNGT-supervised demarcation of the 1-in-100-year Yamuna floodplain
Practice
4 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography