·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityEnvironment

Why are environmental baselines essential for fixing ecological liability in India? Suggest institutional reforms.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why baselines are essential
  2. Institutional reforms

An environmental baseline is the recorded condition of a site before an activity begins. It is the reference point against which damage is measured. Section 20 of the NGT Act, 2010 requires the Tribunal to apply the polluter pays and precautionary principles [1]. Polluter pays only works if a specific harm can be traced to a specific polluter, and that needs a baseline.

Why baselines are essential

  • Proving causation: a survey taken only after the harm shows that damage exists. It cannot show who caused it. The Yamuna floodplain (World Culture Festival, 2016) dispute became one expert opinion against another because no survey of the site's earlier condition existed.
  • Measuring compensation: compensation is meant to repair harm, so it has to match the damage. A figure fixed before any harm is assessed is arbitrary and easy to overturn on appeal.
  • Separating many polluters: the Yamuna floodplain has suffered years of encroachment. Over 1,400 acres have been reclaimed under NGT supervision [3]. Without a baseline, one event's harm cannot be separated from this older degradation.
  • Due process: liability without proof is unfair to the accused. If the accused escape, the public pays for restoration, which reverses polluter pays.
  • Existing precedent: the EIA Notification, 2006 already requires baseline data on environmental components for listed projects [2]. Temporary uses of sensitive land have no such requirement.

Institutional reforms

  • Map sensitive land first: finish and publish floodplain and wetland boundaries. Delhi has already put up GPS-marked bollards along the 1-in-25-year floodplain [3]. Do the same for other cities.
  • Survey before permission: any temporary use of eco-sensitive land should require a time-stamped survey of soil, vegetation and wetland condition, using satellite imagery. The party asking to use the land should pay for it.
  • Deposit first, settle later: treat money taken before an event as a security deposit. Fix the final compensation by comparing a survey taken afterwards with the baseline.
  • Regulator accountability: land-allotting agencies such as the DDA should share liability when they grant permission without a baseline.
  • Standard methods: CPCB should issue standard protocols for damage assessment so that NGT findings hold up on appeal.

Baselines turn polluter pays from a broad slogan into liability that can be proved in court, and they protect both ecology and due process. If baselines are made a routine condition of permissions, the precautionary principle in Section 20 applies before the harm happens rather than years after it. That would advance SDG 15 (life on land).

Sources

  1. 1The National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 (Act No. 19 of 2010), India CodeSection 20: sustainable development, precautionary and polluter pays principles
  2. 2EIA Notification, 2006 (S.O. 1533(E)), MoEFCCAppendix III generic EIA structure requiring baseline data on environmental components
  3. 3DPCC Monthly Progress Report to NGT, OA 673/2020 (Delhi), March 2026, NMCGencroached floodplain reclaimed; 1-in-25-year floodplain marked with GPS bollards
Practice
4 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography