How can courts and police be made more responsive to online gender abuse without curbing free speech?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The IT Rules, 2021 already require intermediaries to remove morphed or intimate imagery within 24 hours of a complaint [1], yet the Delhi High Court had to direct Meta in September 2026 to pull down a morphed photograph of a woman [2]. The deficit is one of responsiveness, not of more restriction.
Why responsiveness falls short today
- The 24-hour duty is only due diligence; ignoring it invites no penalty, merely later loss of safe harbour under Section 79 in litigation [1] — so the victim bears the enforcement cost.
- Shreya Singhal (2015) read down Section 79(3)(b): "actual knowledge" arises from a court or government order, not a private complaint [3].
- Rule 4 automated matching catches only content identical to what was removed [1]; a cropped re-upload escapes.
Making courts more responsive
- Treat a completed MeitY NCII SOP complaint as "actual knowledge", opening the three-hour removal lane to victims, not only the State [4][1].
- Strengthen and publicise Grievance Appellate Committees — 1,065 appeals filed and 937 disposed up to June 2024 [5] — as a free alternative to litigation.
- Extend a single order to future re-uploads of the same image, sparing repeat petitions.
Making police more responsive
- Fixed internal timelines for evidence-preservation requests to platforms before the upload trail is deleted.
- Proceed against circulators, not only the host, as the Court did by issuing notice to those alleged to have spread the image [2].
- Use traceability and labelling duties for synthetically generated content under the 2026 Amendment Rules to identify creators [6].
Safeguards that protect speech
- Confine the fast lane to non-consensual and morphed intimate imagery, a class the Rules already separate [1]; retain reasoned, reviewable process for political speech.
- The 2025 amendment to Rule 3(1)(d) mandates transparency, proportionality and accountability in takedowns [7].
Speed for victims and deliberation for speech are compatible if the law distinguishes categories of harm rather than diluting due process across the board. Victim-facing procedure, trained investigation and published appellate data together advance both Article 21 dignity and Article 19(1)(a) freedoms — an "open, safe and trusted internet" in substance, not slogan.
Sources
- 1IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, as amended — MeitY24-hour removal for morphed/intimate imagery, three-hour compliance on orders, Rules 3 and 4 due diligence, Section 79 safe harbour, Grievance Appellate Committees
- 2Remove morphed photo of woman with PM: HC to Meta (The Hindu, 26 September 2026)Delhi HC direction to Meta, notice to alleged circulators, warning to Delhi Police
- 3The IT (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 — PRS Legislative Research*Shreya Singhal v. Union of India* and the "actual knowledge" standard for intermediaries
- 4SOP on Non-Consensual Intimate Imagery (NCII), version 1 — MeitYvictim-facing takedown procedure for morphed and non-consensual imagery
- 51,065 cases filed and 937 disposed of by the Grievance Appellate Committees under IT Rules, 2021 — PIBGAC caseload data, March 2023 to June 2024
- 6Government Strengthens Regulatory Framework to Address AI-Generated Deepfakes — PIBIT Amendment Rules, 2026 on synthetically generated information, in force 20 February 2026
- 7Government notifies amendments to Rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules, 2021 — PIBtransparency, proportionality and accountability safeguards for takedowns