·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityDefence

Analyse the interplay between the Centre and the State in declaring 'disturbed areas', with reference to Manipur.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Powers are shared, accountability is not
  2. State-led rollback (2022–23)
  3. Centre-led reassertion (2024–26)
  4. The structural asymmetry

Under Section 3 of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958, a 'disturbed area' may be declared either by the Governor of the State or by the Central Government [1]. This concurrent authority makes every declaration a negotiated federal act rather than a unilateral one — a point Manipur's recent record illustrates sharply.

Powers are shared, accountability is not

  • Section 3 vests the notifying power in the State's Governor and the Centre; but Section 6 vests sanction for prosecuting armed forces personnel solely in the Central Government [1].
  • The State thus controls the ground-level law-and-order assessment, while the Centre controls the forces deployed and their legal protection [1].

State-led rollback (2022–23)

  • Manipur's Home Department issues its own Section 3 notifications, and citing an improved security situation it progressively withdrew coverage from valley police stations from April 2022 [4].
  • The Centre endorsed and extended this calibration, further reducing disturbed areas in Nagaland, Assam and Manipur from 1 April 2023 [2].

Centre-led reassertion (2024–26)

  • After ethnic violence from 3 May 2023, the rollback was partly reversed and valley police stations were renotified in November 2024.
  • President's Rule (Feb 2025–Feb 2026) collapsed the distinction altogether: the Governor's Section 3 power was exercised under Union authority.
  • Today the whole State stays notified except 13 police stations in five valley districts [3].

The structural asymmetry

  • Six-monthly renewals need no parliamentary approval, unlike a proclamation under Article 356; a State's dissent carries persuasive, not legal, force.
  • Yet notifications are now drawn police-station-wise, showing the Centre does respond to State assessments [3].

The interplay is therefore cooperative during de-escalation and Centre-dominated during escalation. A statutory duty to record reasons, consult the State, and table renewal notifications in Parliament — alongside the Jeevan Reddy Committee's proposal to relocate these powers into a general law [5] — would align the disturbed-area regime with cooperative federalism and Article 21 safeguards.

Sources

  1. 1The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958 — MHASection 3 dual notifying authority (Governor/Central Government); Section 6 sanction vested in the Centre
  2. 2PIB, Government of India again reduces disturbed areas under AFSPA in Nagaland, Assam and Manipur (2023)Centre-endorsed reduction of disturbed areas from 1 April 2023
  3. 3MHA, Major Initiatives and Peace Process in North Eastern States (April 2026)current notified extent; revocation from 13 police stations in 5 Manipur districts; police-station-level calibration
  4. 4MHA-hosted Government of Manipur AFSPA notificationState Home Department issues its own Section 3 notifications for valley police stations
  5. 5Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 34 (25.11.2014), MHAJeevan Reddy Committee: repeal AFSPA and insert its provisions into the UAPA, 1967
Practice
11 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity