"Civilisational narratives are increasingly used as instruments of foreign policy." Critically analyse in the Indian context.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
A civilisational narrative presents a country's foreign policy as coming from its long cultural history, not only from its interests. India now uses this framing often. Examples range from "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" to hosting the SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum in New Delhi on 20–22 November 2026 [1]. The trend is real, but it works better in some settings than in others.
How India uses civilisational narratives
- Setting summit agendas: India's G20 Presidency theme, "One Earth, One Family, One Future", comes from the Maha Upanishad [2]. It put Global South priorities in moral language.
- Building institutions from heritage: India revived Nalanda University with East Asia Summit countries and opened its Rajgir campus in 2024 [3]. This deepens Buddhist and knowledge links with East Asia.
- Opening stalled channels: India's culture ministry invited all SCO members, Pakistan included. Pakistan accepted and is sending a Federal Minister to Delhi. Days after the two countries clashed at the UN, an Indian official had also gone to Islamabad for SCO planning [1].
- Standing apart from others: It presents India as a "civilisational state" that offers dialogue. This sets it apart from powers that act only through transactions.
Limits and risks
- Others may read it differently: An Indian Minister spoke of a "shared civilisation". Pakistan instead spoke of its own "diverse civilisational and cultural heritage" and said it was attending under the "Shanghai Spirit" [1]. A phrase meant as a bridge can sound like a denial of Pakistan's separate identity.
- No real agenda: Pakistan's stated agenda left out every bilateral issue. Its sideline meetings were promised to "SCO member states" in general, not to India [1]. Culture opens doors, but it cannot settle disputes over terrorism or trade.
- Mixed signals: Engaging soon after a UN clash can weaken India's message that talks and terror cannot go together. It also lets Pakistan claim a "constructive role" [1].
- Show over substance: One-off events without lasting ICCR exchanges can stay symbolic.
Civilisational narratives are therefore a useful complement: they help set agendas, build networks and keep low-cost channels open. They cannot replace diplomacy based on interests. India should make them lasting through scholar and museum exchanges, use a "plural heritage" framing with sensitive neighbours, and link them to concrete results. Used this way, they support Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and the aim in Article 51 of promoting international peace.
Sources
- 1Pakistan Minister to lead delegation to Delhi for SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum, The Hindu, 19 November 2026Forum dates and venue; culture ministry's invitation; Pakistani Minister's attendance; Islamabad planning visit after the UN clash; "shared civilisation" versus "diverse heritage" and "Shanghai Spirit"; Pakistan's stated agenda and sideline meetings (I could not open the article page itself, so the link is The Hindu's homepage)
- 2PIB: India's G20 Presidency logo, theme and website, "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam – One Earth, One Family, One Future"G20 theme and its Maha Upanishad origin (the exact release could not be opened, so the link is PIB's homepage)
- 3PIB: PM inaugurates Nalanda University Campus in Rajgir, Bihar (19 June 2024)Nalanda revived with East Asia Summit countries; Rajgir campus opened in 2024