·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsIR

"Cultural diplomacy in multilateral forums can create openings where bilateral diplomacy has stalled." Discuss with reference to India's hosting of the SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How the multilateral cultural track creates openings
  2. Limits of such openings

Cultural diplomacy means using heritage, ideas and people-to-people ties to build trust between states. India is hosting the SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum in New Delhi (20–22 November 2026), and Pakistan has sent a Federal Minister to it even though bilateral ties remain frozen [1]. This shows that culture inside a multilateral setting can open a door, though it cannot settle a dispute.

How the multilateral cultural track creates openings

  • Low-stakes agenda: The themes are dialogue among civilisations and the "Shanghai Spirit". Terrorism, trade and visas are not on the table, so attending costs either side little politically [1].
  • A duty to the group, not a bilateral concession: Pakistan attends as an "active SCO member state" [1]. Neither government has to tell its home audience that it has softened.
  • Sequenced, reciprocal contact: A senior Indian official went to Islamabad for SCO planning days after the two countries clashed at the UN. A Pakistani minister is now in Delhi [1].
  • Sideline space: Thematic sessions and sideline meetings with SCO members [1] give India informal access to Central Asia, Russia and China.
  • Host's soft power: The invitation came from the Culture Ministry [1]. This brings line ministries into diplomacy and shows off India's civilisational heritage at a time when SAARC is stalled.

Limits of such openings

  • Competing narratives: India speaks of a "shared civilisation", while Pakistan stresses its own "diverse civilisational and cultural heritage" [1]. A framing that India sees as a bridge can sound to Pakistan like a denial of its separate identity.
  • No bilateral content: Pakistan's statement promises sideline meetings only with "SCO member states" in general, not with India [1].
  • Mixed signals: Engaging right after the UN clash lets Pakistan present its "constructive role" to the world [1].
  • Unclear protocol signal: Pakistan sent its Climate Change Minister, not its Culture or Foreign Minister [1]. This could mean it wants a low profile, or that it chose a trusted envoy.

Multilateral cultural diplomacy keeps a working channel open at little cost, but it supports bilateral resolution rather than replacing it. India should turn the moment into lasting links, such as ICCR-led scholar and museum exchanges across the SCO, and watch the level of contact at the next SCO meetings. Steady engagement of this kind fits the Article 51 ideal of promoting international peace and India's ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam.

Sources

  1. 1Pakistan Minister to lead delegation to Delhi for SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum, The Hindu (19 November 2026)Forum dates and venue; Pakistan's delegation led by its Climate Change Minister; invitation from the Culture Ministry; "Shanghai Spirit" and "active SCO member state" wording; Indian official's Islamabad visit after the UN clash; "shared civilisation" vs "diverse civilisational heritage"; thematic sessions and sideline meetings
Practice
5 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on IR