Examine how useful the SCO is to India as a channel for managing relations with Pakistan and China.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) is a permanent intergovernmental body. It is built on the "Shanghai Spirit" of mutual trust, equality and respect for cultural diversity [5]. It is one of the few forums where India sits at the same table as both its difficult neighbours. Its main use is to keep channels open on India's terms. It is less useful for settling disputes.
Usefulness vis-à-vis Pakistan
- Contact without a bilateral concession: a senior Indian official went to Islamabad for an SCO planning meeting days after the two countries clashed at the UN. Pakistan's Climate Change Minister then led its delegation to the SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum, held in New Delhi from 20 to 22 November 2026 [1].
- Face-saving: each visit can be presented as a duty to the group's calendar, so neither side looks like it is softening.
- A platform for India's terrorism narrative: at the Qingdao Defence Ministers' Meeting (2025), India said there should be no "double standards" on cross-border terrorism [4]. At the Tianjin Summit, the PM raised the Pahalgam attack before all members [3].
Usefulness vis-à-vis China
- Leader-level reset on the sidelines: at Tianjin (2025), Modi and Xi called the two countries "development partners rather than rivals" and discussed direct flights and easier visas [2].
- Strategic autonomy: at the same meeting, both sides said India–China ties should not be seen through a third-country lens [2]. The SCO lets India deal with China, Russia and Central Asia without joining any bloc.
Limitations
- No bilateral agenda: Pakistan spoke only of sideline meetings with "SCO member states" in general. No India–Pakistan talks were announced, and disputes such as terrorism and trade are left untouched [1].
- Image management: Pakistan uses SCO events to present its own "constructive role" [1].
- Competing framings: India speaks of a "shared civilisation", while Pakistan stresses its own "diverse civilisational and cultural heritage" [1]. Cultural outreach can therefore cause friction as well as goodwill.
- Structural asymmetry: China's closeness to Pakistan limits how far SCO outcomes reflect India's concerns.
In short, the SCO is a low-cost, steady channel for managing two adversarial relationships. It does not resolve them. India should keep the cultural track going through ICCR exchanges, push counter-terrorism cooperation through RATS, and stay firm bilaterally. This fits Article 51's aim of promoting international peace and India's commitment to strategic autonomy.
Sources
- 1Pakistan Minister to lead delegation to Delhi for SCO Civilisations Dialogue Forum, The Hindu, 19 November 2026(section link: the article page itself could not be checked because the site blocks automated access) — Islamabad planning visit after the UN clash; Pakistan's delegation leader and Forum dates; "SCO member states" sideline meetings; "constructive role"; "shared civilisation" vs "diverse civilisational and cultural heritage"
- 2PIB: Prime Minister's bilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping (Tianjin, 2025)"development partners rather than rivals"; direct flights and visas; no third-country lens
- 3PIB: Prime Minister participates in the 25th SCO Summit in Tianjin, ChinaPahalgam attack raised at the SCO summit
- 4PIB: Raksha Mantri at SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting at Qingdao, Chinano "double standards" on cross-border terrorism
- 5SCO Secretariat: What is the SCO?SCO as a permanent intergovernmental organisation; "Shanghai Spirit" principles