Examine the significance and challenges of implementing one-third reservation for women in legislatures through Constitutional amendment.

Q. Examine the significance and challenges of implementing one-third reservation for women in legislatures through Constitutional amendment. (15 marks, 250-350 words)

The Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023 — Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam, notified on 28 September 2023 — reserves one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha, State Legislative Assemblies and the Delhi Assembly for women [1]. With women forming only about 14% of the 18th Lok Sabha [4], the amendment is a structural corrective; yet its worth turns on when and how it is operationalised.

Significance - Corrects a persistent representation deficit: women are roughly half the electorate but a seventh of the House [4]; reservation converts numbers into legislative presence. - Constitutional entrenchment: routed through Article 368, it cannot be undone by an ordinary law, unlike earlier failed Bills since 1996. - Intersectional reach: the quota operates within seats reserved for SCs and STs, protecting doubly-marginalised women [2]. - Federal depth: extending to all State Assemblies, it scales up the 73rd/74th Amendment panchayat experience, where reserved seats visibly shifted local agendas toward water, health and schooling.

Challenges - Deferred commencement: reservation takes effect only after delimitation based on the first census after 2023 [2] — postponing benefit by an uncertain span. - Contested fast-tracking: the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, 2026, which sought to delink the quota from the post-2026 census and enable rollout by 2029, was negatived in the Lok Sabha in April 2026 [5], leaving the timeline unresolved. - Rotation of reserved seats after each delimitation discourages sustained constituency nurturing and long-term political investment [3]. - No OBC sub-quota, a central objection that stalled earlier Bills and persists [3]. - Proxy representation ("sarpanch-pati") and elite capture risk reducing seats to nominal inclusion rather than real decision-making power [3].

Reservation is a necessary threshold, not a sufficient one. Predictable commencement, intra-party ticket reforms, capacity-building for first-time legislators and campaign-finance support can convert quotas into genuine agency. Delivered thus, the amendment advances Article 15's promise of substantive equality and SDG 5's target of women's full participation in political leadership.

(~325 words)

Sources: 1. PIB, Year End Review 2023: Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs — notification of the 106th Amendment on 28 September 2023; scope covering Lok Sabha, State Assemblies and Delhi 2. PRS Legislative Research, Bill Summary: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023 — quota applies within SC/ST reserved seats; commencement contingent on post-2023 census and delimitation 3. PRS Legislative Research, Issues to Consider: Women's Reservation Bill, 2023 — rotation of seats, absence of OBC sub-quota, proxy/effectiveness concerns 4. Election Commission of India, Statistical Reports, General Election to Lok Sabha 2024 — share of women members in the 18th Lok Sabha 5. PRS Legislative Research, The Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, 2026 — proposal to delink reservation from the post-2026 census; Bill negatived in Lok Sabha, April 2026