Print Culture and the Modern World
In this note
- Print in East Asia: the first printed books
- Print comes to Europe: Gutenberg and the print revolution
- Impact in Europe: new reading public, religious debate and dissent
- The reading mania and the French Revolution
- The nineteenth century in Europe: new readers, new technology
- Print comes to India: manuscripts, missionaries, first newspapers
- Religious reform and public debates in print
- New forms of publication and visual culture
- Women and print
- Print, the poor and caste-class critique
- Print, censorship and nationalism
- Exam angles
1. Print in East Asia: the first printed books
- The earliest print technology — hand printing — developed in China, Japan and Korea. From AD 594, books in China were printed by rubbing paper (also invented in China) against inked woodblocks; since only one side of the thin porous sheet could be printed, the traditional Chinese 'accordion book' was folded and stitched at the side. Craftsmen reproduced calligraphy with remarkable accuracy.
- The imperial state was the major producer of print: China's vast bureaucracy recruited through civil service examinations, whose textbooks were printed in huge state-sponsored volumes (rising further as candidates increased from the sixteenth century).
- Seventeenth-century diversification with urban culture: merchants used print for trade information; reading became leisure (fiction, poetry, autobiographies, anthologies, romantic plays); rich women began to read and publish — scholar-officials' wives and courtesans wrote.
- Western mechanical presses were imported in the late nineteenth century; Shanghai became the hub of the new print culture — a gradual shift from hand printing to mechanical printing.
- Japan: Buddhist missionaries from China brought hand printing c. AD 768–770; the Diamond Sutra (AD 868), six sheets of text with woodcut illustrations, is the oldest printed book (the chapter's phrasing: "the oldest Chinese book"). Pictures were printed on textiles, playing cards, paper money. In late-eighteenth-century Edo (Tokyo), ukiyo ('pictures of the floating world') prints of Kitagawa Utamaro (b. 1753) travelled to the West and influenced Manet, Monet and Van Gogh.
- Korea: the Tripitaka Koreana — Buddhist scriptures on about 80,000 woodblocks (mid-13th century), UNESCO Memory of the World Register 2007; the Jikji (late 14th century, Zen Buddhism) — among the world's oldest existing books printed with movable metal type, Memory of the World 2001; its surviving second volume is in the National Library of France.
2. Print comes to Europe: Gutenberg and the print revolution
- Chinese paper reached Europe in the eleventh century via the silk route, enabling scribal manuscripts; in 1295 Marco Polo brought woodblock printing knowledge back to Italy, and the technology spread across Europe.
- Luxury editions remained handwritten on vellum (animal-skin parchment) for aristocrats and monastic libraries, which scoffed at printed books as "cheap vulgarities"; merchants and students bought cheaper printed copies. Booksellers exporting across Europe employed scribes — often more than 50 per bookseller — but hand copying was slow, costly, and manuscripts fragile; by the early fifteenth century woodblocks widely printed textiles, playing cards and religious pictures.
- Johann Gutenberg developed the first-known printing press at Strasbourg in the 1430s, perfecting it by 1448: raised on an agricultural estate, he knew wine and olive presses, and was a master goldsmith expert in lead moulds — the olive press became the model for the printing press, moulds cast the metal types. He made types for the 26 Roman letters — the moveable type machine, the basic print technology for the next 300 years, printing 250 sheets an hour on one side.
- First printed book: the Bible — about 180 copies in three years (no more than 50 survive). Early printed books imitated manuscripts: ornamental letters, hand-illuminated borders, blank space for bespoke decoration in copies for the rich — elites prized this non-uniformity (no two copies identical).
- Between 1450 and 1550 presses appeared in most European countries; the later fifteenth century saw 20 million printed books, the sixteenth century about 200 million — the shift from hand to mechanical printing was the print revolution. (Terms: platen, compositor, galley.)
3. Impact in Europe: new reading public, religious debate and dissent
- Printing cut costs: a reading public emerged where there had been a hearing public living in oral culture (sacred texts read out, ballads recited, folk tales narrated). But literacy stayed very low till the twentieth century, so printers published illustrated ballads and folk tales to be sung and recited in villages and taverns — oral culture entered print and printed material was orally transmitted; the two publics intermingled.
- Print let dissenters circulate ideas widely — hence the fear of print among religious authorities, monarchs, writers: uncontrolled printing might spread "rebellious and irreligious" thoughts. Erasmus in Adages (1508) condemned the "swarms of new books" — a glut of "stupid, ignorant, slanderous, scandalous, raving, irreligious and seditious" print devaluing even valuable works.
- Print and the Reformation: in 1517 Martin Luther printed his Ninety Five Theses against Catholic practices, a copy posted on the Wittenberg church door; his writings were mass-reproduced and his New Testament translation sold 5,000 copies in a few weeks (second edition within three months), dividing the Church and beginning the Protestant Reformation. Luther: "Printing is the ultimate gift of God and the greatest one."
- Dissent from below: Menocchio, a sixteenth-century Italian miller, reinterpreted the Bible from local books, enraged the Church, was twice hauled up by the Inquisition and executed. The Church imposed controls on publishers and kept an Index of Prohibited Books from 1558.
4. The reading mania and the French Revolution
- Church-run village schools raised literacy through the 17th–18th centuries — 60–80 per cent in parts of Europe by the late eighteenth century: a reading mania. Booksellers employed pedlars; new cheap forms: almanacs, ballads, folktales; England's penny chapbooks (sold by chapmen); France's Bibliotheque Bleue (cheap small books in blue covers); the periodical press from the early eighteenth century mixed current affairs with entertainment.
- Science and philosophy were popularised: Newton's discoveries, and the writings of Thomas Paine, Voltaire and Rousseau — ideas of science, reason and rationality entered popular literature. Mercier (French novelist): "The printing press is the most powerful engine of progress and public opinion is the force that will sweep despotism away" — "Tremble, therefore, tyrants of the world!"
-
Print and the French Revolution — three arguments (presented in the chapter as a historians' debate): 1. Print popularised Enlightenment ideas attacking tradition, superstition, despotism and the Church's sacred authority (Voltaire, Rousseau widely read). 2. Print created a new culture of dialogue and debate in which all values and institutions were re-evaluated — ideas of social revolution emerged. 3. By the 1780s, underground literature, cartoons and caricatures mocked royalty and its morality, feeding hostility to the monarchy.
-
Caveat: people also read monarchical and Church propaganda; they accepted some ideas and rejected others. Print did not directly shape minds — it opened up the possibility of thinking differently.
5. The nineteenth century in Europe: new readers, new technology
- Children: compulsory primary education (late 19th century) made textbooks critical; a children's press was founded in France in 1857; the Grimm Brothers published their edited collection of peasant folk tales in 1812 — print recorded old tales but also changed them.
- Women: readers and writers — penny magazines and conduct manuals targeted them; novelists Jane Austen, the Bronte sisters, George Eliot defined a new type of woman with will, personality and the power to think.
- Workers: lending libraries (from the 17th century) educated white-collar workers, artisans and the lower middle class; with shorter working days from the mid-nineteenth century, self-educated workers wrote political tracts and autobiographies (Maxim Gorky's My Childhood and My University record such struggles).
- Technology: Richard M. Hoe (New York) perfected the power-driven cylindrical press by the mid-nineteenth century — 8,000 sheets per hour, ideal for newspapers; the late-century offset press printed six colours; electric presses from c. 1900, plus better paper feeding, plates, automatic paper reels and photoelectric colour controls.
- Marketing: serialised novels in periodicals; the 1920s Shilling Series; the twentieth-century dust jacket; cheap paperbacks to sustain sales in the 1930s Great Depression.
6. Print comes to India: manuscripts, missionaries, first newspapers
- Manuscripts before print: a rich tradition in Sanskrit, Arabic, Persian and vernaculars, copied on palm leaves or handmade paper, illustrated, preserved between wooden covers — and still produced till the late nineteenth century. But manuscripts were expensive, fragile, written in varied scripts and hard to read — not for everyday use. In pre-colonial Bengal's extensive village primary schools, students often only learnt to write, taking dictation from memory — literate without ever reading texts.
- Arrival: the press came to Goa with Portuguese missionaries in the mid-sixteenth century; Jesuits printed Konkani tracts — about 50 books in Konkani and Kanara by 1674. Catholic priests printed the first Tamil book in 1579 at Cochin and the first Malayalam book in 1713; by 1710 Dutch Protestant missionaries had printed 32 Tamil texts, many translations.
- The English press grew late although the East India Company imported presses from the late seventeenth century (William Bolts's 1768 Calcutta notice came to nothing).
- From 1780 James Augustus Hickey edited the weekly Bengal Gazette — "a commercial paper open to all, but influenced by none": private English enterprise, independent of colonial influence, began English printing in India. Hickey printed advertisements (including for the sale of slaves) and gossip about senior Company officials — Governor-General Warren Hastings persecuted him and encouraged officially sanctioned newspapers to counter damaging reports.
- The first Indian-published newspaper: the weekly Bengal Gazette of Gangadhar Bhattacharya, close to Rammohun Roy.
7. Religious reform and public debates in print
- From the early nineteenth century, reform controversies — widow immolation, monotheism, Brahmanical priesthood, idolatry — were fought out in print. Tracts and newspapers not only spread ideas: they shaped the very nature of the debate, printed in the everyday spoken language so a wider public could join in.
| Publication | Year | Language / association |
|---|---|---|
| Bengal Gazette (Hickey) | 1780 | English weekly — first newspaper in India |
| Bengal Gazette (Gangadhar Bhattacharya) | — | first Indian-published newspaper |
| Sambad Kaumudi | 1821 | Bengali — Rammohun Roy |
| Samachar Chandrika | — | commissioned by the Hindu orthodoxy against Roy |
| Jam-i-Jahan Nama, Shamsul Akhbar | 1822 | Persian |
| Bombay Samachar | 1822 | Gujarati |
- Muslim north India: the ulama, fearing colonial conversion drives and changes to Muslim personal law, used cheap lithographic presses for Persian/Urdu scripture translations and religious tracts; the Deoband Seminary (1867) issued thousands of fatwas on everyday conduct; rival sects fought their battles publicly through Urdu print.
- Hindu vernacular publishing: the first printed Ramcharitmanas (Tulsidas, 16th-century text) appeared from Calcutta in 1810; cheap lithographic editions flooded north India by mid-century; from the 1880s the Naval Kishore Press (Lucknow) and Shri Venkateshwar Press (Bombay) printed numerous vernacular religious texts — portable, readable anywhere, and read aloud to the illiterate.
- Print stirred controversy within and among religions but also connected communities across regions: newspapers conveyed news between places, creating pan-Indian identities.
8. New forms of publication and visual culture
- Readers wanted their own lives reflected in print: the novel acquired distinctively Indian forms; new forms followed — lyrics, short stories, political and social essays — stressing human lives and intimate feelings.
- A new visual culture by the century's end: Raja Ravi Varma produced mythological images for mass circulation; wood engravers set up near letterpresses; cheap prints and calendars in the bazaar — affordable even to the poor — shaped popular ideas of modernity and tradition, religion and politics.
- Caricatures and cartoons from the 1870s: some ridiculed educated Indians' Western tastes; imperial cartoons lampooned nationalists (e.g. the Indian Charivari), nationalist cartoons criticised imperial rule.
- Calcutta's Battala quarter printed cheap religious tracts alongside 'obscene' popular literature, profusely illustrated with woodcuts and coloured lithographs; pedlars carried Battala books into homes, letting women read in their leisure time. (Assam: Lakshminath Bezbaruah, doyen of modern Assamese literature — Burhi Aair Sadhu.)
9. Women and print
- Women's reading rose enormously in middle-class homes: liberal husbands and fathers educated womenfolk at home or in the new women's schools (after the mid-nineteenth century); journals carried women's writing and syllabi for home-based schooling.
- Conservative fears: Hindus — a literate girl would be widowed; Muslims — educated women would be corrupted by Urdu romances. Women rebelled: a north-Indian Muslim girl secretly learnt Urdu; in East Bengal Rashsundari Debi learnt to read in the secrecy of her kitchen and wrote Amar Jiban (1876) — the first full-length autobiography in Bengali.
- From the 1860s Kailashbashini Debi wrote of women imprisoned at home, kept ignorant, worked hard and treated unjustly; in the 1880s (present-day Maharashtra) Tarabai Shinde and Pandita Ramabai wrote with passionate anger about upper-caste Hindu women, especially widows.
- Hindi printing began seriously only from the 1870s — a large segment soon devoted to women's education; early-twentieth-century journals for (and sometimes edited by) women covered education, widowhood, widow remarriage and the national movement, plus household lessons and serialised fiction.
- Punjab: Ram Chaddha's fast-selling Istri Dharm Vichar and the Khalsa Tract Society's cheap booklets taught women obedience — often dialogues on the "good woman". In 1926 Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossein condemned men for withholding education from women in religion's name, against Islam's own tenet of women's equal right to education.
10. Print, the poor and caste-class critique
- Very cheap small books were sold at crossroads in nineteenth-century Madras towns; public libraries spread from the early twentieth century (cities, towns, some prosperous villages) — for rich patrons a library brought prestige.
- Caste critique: Jyotiba Phule, Maratha pioneer of 'low caste' protest, attacked the caste system's injustices in Gulamgiri (1871); in the twentieth century B.R. Ambedkar (Maharashtra) and E.V. Ramaswamy Naicker — Periyar (Madras) wrote powerfully on caste, read all over India; protest movements produced journals criticising ancient scriptures and envisioning a just future.
- Worker writing: Kashibaba, a Kanpur millworker, published Chhote Aur Bade Ka Sawal (1938) linking caste and class exploitation; fellow Kanpur millworker Sudarshan Chakr's poems (1935–55) were collected as Sacchi Kavitayan; by the 1930s Bangalore cotton millworkers set up self-education libraries (following Bombay workers), sponsored by reformers seeking temperance, literacy and sometimes nationalism.
11. Print, censorship and nationalism
- Before 1798 the Company cared little for censorship; its early controls targeted critical Englishmen — lest their attacks on Company misrule arm the Company's critics in England against its trade monopoly.
- 1820s: Calcutta Supreme Court regulations on press freedom; Company-encouraged loyalist papers. 1835: after editors' petitions, Governor-General Bentinck had Thomas Macaulay frame rules restoring earlier freedoms.
- After 1857, enraged Englishmen demanded a clampdown on the 'native' press. The Vernacular Press Act (1878), modelled on the Irish Press Laws, gave government extensive rights to censor reports and editorials in the vernacular press: papers were tracked province by province; a 'seditious' report drew a warning; if ignored, the press was liable to seizure and the machinery to confiscation.
- Repression bred a cycle of persecution and protest as nationalist papers multiplied. When Punjab revolutionaries were deported in 1907, Tilak's Kesari defended them — his imprisonment in 1908 sparked all-India protests. (Government struggled even to hire loyalist editors: the Statesman's Sanders demanded compensation for lost freedom; the Friend of India refused a subsidy.)
- Wartime suppression: WWI Defence of India Rules — of 22 papers ordered to furnish securities, 18 shut down; the Rowlatt Sedition Committee Report (1919) tightened controls; WWII's Defence of India Act censored war reporting including all Quit India news — about 90 newspapers suppressed in August 1942.
- Gandhi (1922): "Liberty of speech … liberty of the press … freedom of association … The fight for Swaraj, for Khilafat … means a fight for this threatened freedom before all else."
Exam angles
Prelims:
- Newspaper/author pairings: Bengal Gazette — Hickey (1780) vs Bengal Gazette — Gangadhar Bhattacharya (first Indian-published); Sambad Kaumudi — Rammohun Roy (1821); Samachar Chandrika — Hindu orthodoxy; Bombay Samachar — Gujarati (1822); Kesari — Tilak; Amar Jiban — Rashsundari Debi (1876); Gulamgiri — Phule (1871); Chhote Aur Bade Ka Sawal — Kashibaba (1938); Sacchi Kavitayan — Sudarshan Chakr; Istri Dharm Vichar — Ram Chaddha.
- Chronology of firsts: China AD 594; Japan AD 768–770; Diamond Sutra AD 868; Jikji (movable metal type) and Tripitaka Koreana (~80,000 blocks) — UNESCO Memory of the World; paper to Europe 11th century; Marco Polo 1295; Gutenberg 1430s (perfected 1448, Bible ~180 copies); Luther 1517; Index of Prohibited Books 1558; Goa press mid-16th century; first Tamil book 1579; first Malayalam book 1713; Hickey 1780; Ramcharitmanas printed 1810; Deoband 1867; Vernacular Press Act 1878.
- Censorship sequence: pre-1798 controls on Englishmen → 1820s Supreme Court regulations → 1835 Bentinck-Macaulay liberalisation → post-1857 hardening → Vernacular Press Act 1878 (Irish Press Laws model; warn → seize) → Tilak jailed 1908 → WWI rules (18 of 22 papers shut) → Rowlatt 1919 → ~90 papers suppressed August 1942.
- Trap statements (mark FALSE): "Gutenberg invented paper / woodblock printing" (both Chinese); "Hickey's was the first Indian-published newspaper" (Bhattacharya's); "the Vernacular Press Act covered the English press" (vernacular only); "print reached India with the British" (Portuguese, Goa); "Hindi print culture developed earliest" (seriously only from the 1870s — Urdu, Tamil, Bengali, Marathi earlier).
- Terms: calligraphy, accordion book, ukiyo, vellum, platen, compositor, galley, chapbook/chapman, Bibliotheque Bleue, almanac, ulama, fatwa, lithography, Battala; Hoe cylindrical press (8,000 sheets/hr), offset press (six colours).
Mains:
- "Explain how print culture assisted the growth of nationalism in India" (GS-I staple): vernacular papers reporting misrule, pan-Indian identity through circulation, the persecution-protest cycle (Tilak), press freedom itself a nationalist demand (Gandhi 1922).
- Print and religious/social reform — printed tracts shaped the very nature of public debate: Rammohun Roy vs the orthodoxy, Deoband's lithographed fatwas, cheap vernacular scriptures.
- Print and marginalised voices — women's autobiography and journals (Rashsundari Debi, Tarabai Shinde, Ramabai, Rokeya Hossein), caste protest (Phule, Ambedkar, Periyar), worker writing (Kashibaba): print as instrument of social emancipation.
- Europe: does print cause revolutions? The three French Revolution arguments plus the chapter's caveat — print "opened up the possibility of thinking differently"; parallels in the Reformation (Luther) and the fear of print (Erasmus, the Index).
- Colonial censorship as a window on the colonial state: from shielding the Company's image against Englishmen to the Vernacular Press Act and wartime suppression — the changing logic of control tracks rising nationalism.
Detailed notes
- Print in East Asia: the first printed books
- Print comes to Europe: Gutenberg and the print revolution
- Impact in Europe: new reading public, religious debate and dissent
- The reading mania and the French Revolution
- The nineteenth century in Europe: new readers, new technology
- Print comes to India: manuscripts, missionaries, first newspapers
- Religious reform and public debates in print
- New forms of publication and visual culture
- Women and print
- Print, the poor and caste-class critique
- Print, censorship and nationalism