·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityEnvironment

"Multilateral platforms offer India a way to manage adversarial bilateral relationships without compromising on core security concerns." Examine this with reference to India–Pakistan engagement in the SCO.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How the SCO helps India manage the relationship
  2. Limits of the multilateral route
  3. Way forward

After the Pahalgam attack (April 2025), the Cabinet Committee on Security suspended the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) [1], and New Delhi refuses bilateral dialogue while terror continues. Yet India and Pakistan still meet inside the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO). This shows that multilateral forums can keep contact alive without diluting red lines, but only up to a point.

How the SCO helps India manage the relationship

  • Contact without formal talks: PM Modi proposed an SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum at Tianjin [2], and India is hosting its first edition [3], inviting all members, including Pakistan. Engagement happens without reopening bilateral dialogue.
  • Terror on the agenda: At Tianjin, India called for a unified stand against terrorism [2]. At the SCO Heads of Government meeting it urged dismantling the "entire ecosystem of terrorism" [4]. The SCO's RATS (Tashkent) adds a counter-terror track.
  • Precedent: Pakistan's foreign minister attended the 2023 SCO ministers' meeting in Goa under India's chairship, with no bilateral concession from India.
  • Convening power: Hosting all members casts India as a regional leader, not a spoiler.

Limits of the multilateral route

  • Consensus constraint: The SCO works by consensus. In June 2025, India refused to sign an SCO defence ministers' statement that left out Pahalgam.
  • China at the centre: With the Secretariat in Beijing and China close to Pakistan, routing contact through the SCO gives China leverage.
  • Disputes stay unresolved: The SCO cannot settle the IWT. India rejects the Court of Arbitration's competence [5] and prefers the treaty's own Neutral Expert route [6].
  • Messaging dilemma: Pakistan's current SCO chairship forces a visible choice about how senior India's delegation to the next summit will be.
  • Economic cost continues: Trade within South Asia is only ~5% of the region's total trade, against 50% in East Asia [7].

Way forward

  • Calibrated engagement: cooperate on climate, disasters and culture, while keeping the terror red lines firm.
  • Share flood-season data as a humanitarian step, without reviving the treaty.
  • Use SCO summits to put cross-border terrorism on record, including on Pakistan's own ground.

In sum, the SCO lets India talk to Pakistan without conceding on terrorism, but it cannot by itself resolve bilateral disputes or offset China's influence. If India combines firm red lines with issue-based cooperation, it can remain a responsible convening power, in line with its Neighbourhood First policy and SDG-16 (peace and strong institutions).

Sources

  1. 1PIB: Union Home Minister Shri Amit Shah participates in special discussion in Rajya Sabha on Operation Sindoor (30 July 2025): the CCS suspended the IWT after Pahalgam
  2. 2PIB: English translation of Prime Minister's statement during the 25th SCO Summit, Tianjin: proposal for a Civilisational Dialogue Forum; call for unified stand against terrorism
  3. 3PIB: Prime Minister participates in the 26th SCO Summit in Bishkek: India to host the first SCO Civilisation Dialogue Forum
  4. 4PIB: 25th SCO Council of Heads of Government Meeting: Raksha Mantri calls for unified action to dismantle the entire ecosystem of terrorism: India raising terrorism at the SCO
  5. 5MEA: Transcript of Weekly Media Briefing by the Official Spokesperson (14 August 2025): India rejects the Court of Arbitration's legality and competence
  6. 6MEA: Indus Waters Treaty (treaty text), Annexure F: Neutral Expert mechanism
  7. 7World Bank: South Asia Should Remove Trade Barriers for Mutual Economic Gains, *A Glass Half Full* (2018): intra-regional trade at 5% in South Asia vs 50% in East Asia
Practice
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography