·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityEnvironment

"South Asia remains one of the least economically integrated regions in the world." Analyse the causes and the strategic cost to India, including the space this creates for China.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Causes: man-made, not natural
  2. Strategic cost to India
  3. Space created for China

Trade within South Asia is only about 5% of the region's total trade. The figure is 50% for East Asia and the Pacific and 22% for Sub-Saharan Africa [2]. Politics, more than geography, keeps the region apart. India pays the highest price for this, and China gains the most from it.

Causes: man-made, not natural

  • Tariff walls: Average tariffs in South Asia were 13.6% in 2016, more than double the world average of 6.3%. Para-tariffs and non-tariff measures add to them [1].
  • Connectivity costs: Poor border infrastructure and slow logistics make trading with a neighbour costlier than trading with distant partners [1].
  • Trust deficit: The World Bank names this as a separate barrier [1]. After Pahalgam, India closed the Attari Integrated Check Post [3]. SAARC is largely dormant.
  • Asymmetry anxieties: India borders every South Asian state. Its smaller neighbours fear becoming dependent on it [5].

Strategic cost to India

  • Lost economic gains: India's possible goods trade with South Asia was $62 billion, but actual trade was only $19 billion [2].
  • Weak leverage: With little trade to lose, cutting trade gives India little pressure on its neighbours [3]. Trade ties that could have acted as a buffer against hostility were never built.
  • Leadership deficit: India's neighbourhood is unstable, and that weakens its claim to lead the region and its global ambitions [4].

Space created for China

  • Filling the vacuum: Beijing exploits New Delhi's strained ties with its neighbours. It has hosted trilateral meetings with Pakistan–Bangladesh and Afghanistan–Pakistan [4].
  • BRI and arms: India is the only South Asian state that has not endorsed the Belt and Road Initiative. South Asia is also the largest destination for Chinese arms [5].
  • Parallel institutions: China is not a member of South Asian bodies. It builds influence through its own regional groupings instead [5][4].

Low integration therefore costs India in two ways. It loses income, and China gains strategic room in India's neighbourhood. The way forward is to follow the World Bank's advice: cut para-tariffs, upgrade border connectivity and build trust [1]. India can work through sub-regional groups like BBIN and keep its firm line on terror separate from cooperation in other areas. This would turn Neighbourhood First into shared prosperity, in the spirit of SDG 17 (partnerships for the goals).

Sources

  1. 1World Bank press release, "South Asia Can Triple Regional Trade by Removing Trade Barriers" (19 Sept 2018), on *A Glass Half Full*: tariffs of 13.6% vs 6.3%; non-tariff, connectivity and trust barriers; recommendations
  2. 2World Bank press release, "South Asia Should Remove Trade Barriers for Mutual Economic Gains" (24 Sept 2018): ~5% intra-regional share vs 50%/22%; India's $62 bn potential vs $19 bn actual
  3. 3MEA, Transcript of Special Briefing (23 April 2025): CCS decision to close the Attari ICP
  4. 4Chatham House, "Modi's SCO summit visit shows China and India want to reset relations" (Sept 2025): Beijing exploits India's strained ties; China-hosted trilaterals; turbulent neighbourhood
  5. 5Chatham House Research Paper, "How China–India relations will shape Asia and the global order" (April 2025): India borders every South Asian state; only South Asian non-endorser of BRI; largest destination for Chinese arms; China absent from regional bodies
Practice
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography