·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsEconomy

Explain the role of Additional Tier-1 instruments in Basel III. Do recent judicial outcomes weaken their usefulness as loss-absorbing capital in India?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Role of AT-1 in Basel III
  2. How judicial outcomes weaken their usefulness
  3. Why the weakening is limited

Under Basel III, a bank's Tier-1 capital has two parts. The first is Common Equity Tier-1 (CET-1). The second is Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) instruments: perpetual bonds that absorb losses while the bank is still running. In October 2026 the Supreme Court held Yes Bank's ₹8,415-crore AT-1 write-off "impermissible" [1]. The ruling dents the credibility of AT-1, but on procedure rather than on the concept.

Role of AT-1 in Basel III

  • Perpetual capital: AT-1 bonds have no maturity, so banks raise lasting capital without diluting shareholders.
  • Loss absorption: they are written down or converted into equity at a trigger point, and coupons are discretionary.
  • Loss hierarchy: AT-1 ranks above equity but below Tier-2 bonds and deposits, which shields depositors.
  • Resolution tool: the RBI's draft Yes Bank Reconstruction Scheme, 2020, framed under Section 45 of the Banking Regulation Act, provided for a full write-down of AT-1 instruments [2].

How judicial outcomes weaken their usefulness

  • Legal uncertainty: the Bombay High Court set aside the write-off and the Supreme Court upheld it [1]. Investors may now price AT-1 as quasi-debt, which weakens its value as loss-absorbing capital.
  • Capital erosion: restoring the bonds turns capital back into a liability. This reduces the bank's CET-1, its highest-quality capital.
  • Regulatory chill: the RBI's review petition [1] shows its concern that rescues done in days of crisis can be undone years later.
  • Fairness deficit: AT-1 holders were wiped out while equity holders, who rank below them, kept some value. This reversed the normal loss order and undermined the legitimacy of the write-off.

Why the weakening is limited

  • The courts did not reject write-downs as such. They found that this write-off lacked a valid legal basis when it was carried out [1], which is a defect of process.
  • The Basel III design and the contractual write-down clauses remain intact.
  • SEBI now sets a ₹1-crore minimum subscription and trade lot for AT-1 bonds [3]. This keeps retail investors out, so future holders knowingly take the risk and mis-selling disputes become less likely.

Overall, AT-1 remains a vital Basel III buffer, and the Yes Bank verdicts expose gaps in the resolution process rather than flaws in the instrument. Three steps would make future write-downs hold up in court: a statutory bail-in law covering only AT-1 and Tier-2 bonds, with deposits excluded (unlike the withdrawn FRDI Bill, 2017); clear rules on the order of steps in the RBI's Basel III norms; and making equity take losses before AT-1. Together these would protect both financial stability and the rule of law.

Sources

  1. 1RBI seeks review of SC's Yes Bank AT-1 bond order — The Hindu (Reuters), 17 Nov 2026₹8,415-crore write-off held "impermissible"; Bombay HC ruling upheld by SC (Oct 2026); RBI review petition
  2. 2RBI Press Release — Draft Yes Bank Ltd. Reconstruction Scheme, 2020Section 45 BR Act basis; full write-down of AT-1 instruments
  3. 3SEBI — FAQs on the Corporate Bond Market (Oct 2024)₹1-crore minimum subscription and trade lot for AT-1 bonds
Practice
3 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Economy