The Yes Bank AT-1 bond episode shows the tension between the regulator's resolution powers and contract rights. Discuss with reference to recent Supreme Court proceedings.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
In March 2020, the RBI's draft Yes Bank Reconstruction Scheme said that Basel III Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds would be "written down permanently, in full" [2]. In October 2026 the Supreme Court held the ₹8,415-crore write-off impermissible, and the RBI has now sought a review [1]. The case shows the conflict between a fast bank rescue and certainty of contracts.
Supreme Court proceedings
- The Bombay HC (2023) quashed the write-off. On 15 October 2026, the SC upheld that ruling and dismissed the appeals of the RBI, Yes Bank and the Union government [3].
- Ratio: the write-down had to happen before the scheme came into force. The final notified scheme dropped the clause that allowed it, so the administrator had no authority to write the bonds off [3].
- The RBI's review petition (Article 137) is a narrow remedy. It must show an error apparent on the face of the record [1].
Case for the regulator's resolution powers
- Loss absorption is the reason AT-1 counts as capital under Basel III. Investors earn higher coupons for taking this risk [2].
- Speed: bank rescues happen over a weekend. If courts reverse a write-down years later, AT-1 behaves like ordinary debt, and future rescues become costlier.
- Stability: restoring the bonds reduces the rescued bank's CET-1, its purest capital, and weakens the balance sheet the rescue was meant to repair.
Case for contract rights and rule of law
- Legality: state action must rest on the law in force when it acts. A regulator's speed cannot replace legal authority [3].
- Loss hierarchy reversed: equity shareholders, who rank below AT-1 holders, survived, while AT-1 holders were wiped out. This weakens the fairness defence.
- Investor protection: in 2020 SEBI limited AT-1 issues to QIBs, with a ₹1-crore minimum lot, because retail investors may not understand the issuer's discretion over these bonds [4]. That protection came after the damage was done.
The court did not reject loss absorption; it rejected a write-off made without legal authority. Three changes would let rescues be both fast and fair: a statutory bail-in regime limited to AT-1 and Tier-2 bonds, learning from the withdrawn FRDI Bill, 2017; clear rules in the RBI's Basel III framework on the order of steps; and making equity holders take losses first. These steps would keep the RBI's resolution powers while respecting Article 14's guard against arbitrariness.
Sources
- 1RBI seeks review of SC's Yes Bank AT-1 bond order — Reuters/*The Hindu*, 17 Nov 2026, p. 13RBI review petition; SC held ₹8,415-crore write-off impermissible
- 2RBI Press Release — Draft Yes Bank Ltd. Reconstruction Scheme, 2020AT-1 write-down clause; Basel III instruments
- 3Supreme Court of India — judgment in RBI/Yes Bank/Union of India appeals on the AT-1 write-off (15 Oct 2026)upheld Bombay HC (2023); timing of the write-down; administrator lacked authority
- 4SEBI Circular on Issuance, Listing and Trading of AT-1 Instruments (Oct 2020)QIB-only issues, ₹1-crore minimum lot, retail investors' limited understanding